News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Valentine's Day is here and love is all around us. At this most romantic time of the year, we can't help but wonder... what is the greatest Broadway love song ever? BroadwayWorld continues our great tradition of finding that consensus- and this year we have more answers than ever! We've gathered responses from over 1500 performers, composers, industry professionals, and entertainment personalities from all over the world. 

This year's list is presented by The Notebook, now in previews on Broadway. Based on the best selling novel that inspired the iconic film, this new musical follows Allie and Noah, both from different worlds, as they share a lifetime of love despite the forces that threaten to pull them apart, in a deeply moving portrait of the enduring power of love.

Category:
Performer
THE HIGH KINGS | Piano Man in the Movin' Out Tour | Riverdance
"All I Ask of You" from Andrew Lloyd Webber's THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA. Just the aching plea of the song is enough to send shivers through me every time.
Performer
Curtains | Never Gonna Dance | Thoroughly Modern Millie | Follies
You know what, I'm going to say a song that isn't from Broadway - I can't decide between "The Nearness of You" or "What'll I Do?" - they're all very sad...but then again I think it goes back to "If I Loved You" from CAROUSEL. And a good runner up would be "All The Things You Are".
Performer
HAIRSPRAY | Pippin | AIDA
"And This is My Beloved" from KISMET. Besides Borodin's wonderful melody, the lyrics of Robert Wright and George Forrest subtly, yet passionately, describe the indescribable feeling when one meets one's perfect love.
Industry
NJ Star-Ledger
Unquestionably "Blame It on the Summer Night" from RAGS.
Performer
Hamilton | Wicked | In The Heights | Lennon | Aida | Dance of the Vampires
It would have to be "One Hand, One Heart" from WEST SIDE STORY. It fills my heart every time I hear it....
Industry
Producer: Rags | The Secret Garden. Pippin | Children of Eden | Snoopy in Concert
I'm giving you my top 3 because there are different kinds of romantic songs: Melancholy: Unusual Way from NINE- The melody is really lush and haunting and the lyric perfectly describes what it's like to not be able to explain the angst that comes from love. Warm & Tingly: What More Can I Say? from FALSETTOS- sweet and very simple and was the first song in musical theatre that personally spoke to me as a young gay kid who loved showtunes. Uplifting: Listen to My Heart by David Friedman as sung by Nancy LaMott. The most celebratory love song I can think of-you can't help but smile ear-to-ear when you hear Nancy sing it.
Performer
Dirty Rotten Scoundrels | Miss Saigon | Accidental Death of an Anarchist | Comedians
It has to be "Love Sneaks In" from DIRTY ROTTEN SCOUNDRELS. A Valentine song for the more mature man.
Industry
Arranger / Conductor / Musical Director / Supervisor: Threepenny Opera | The Color Purple | Fiddler on the Roof | Nine | Oklahoma! | On the Town | Titanic | Sunset Boulevard
I think the most romantic Broadway love song, for me, is "Not While I'm Around" from SWEENEY TODD. Not for what it says, but for what it does not directly say. The act of protecting someone from all things bad is the most primal form of devotion, love---if not in the standard "I love you, you love me" form. Of course the character who sings this song is not in love in the traditional way. But for him, he is experiencing the most strong and raw emotion that he has ever felt. Quirky, I know, but the combination of sweeping melody, with it's rather wide intervals and plaintive simple lyrics make this the most romantic Broadway love song that I can think of. I know this is not a doctoral thesis, but this song of devotion has moved me more than any other.
Performer
Evita Tour | Les Miserables | A Tale of Two Cities
"With Every Breath I Take" from CITY OF ANGELS. What a way to be thinking of someone you love or lost but still love them. I mean, we breathe every second!
Industry
Choreographer | Director | Performer: My Favorite Year | My One and Only | The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas | Nine | A Chorus Line | Seesaw
(1950-2007) "My Heart is So Full of You", with music and lyrics and music by Frank Loesser from MOST HAPPY FELLA. It's a duet sung by Tony and Rosabella, from a magnificent score with breathtaking emotional melodies. Their love for one another is bursting with passion, not reflected but immediate and it's full of expression. Forgive me Mr. Loesser, but I think that the lyric went something like this: "my heart is so full of you, there is no room for anything more there" Wow! Come on! This knocks me out. I think that I remember that feeling? Do you? Hope so!! Celebrate your partners! Happy Valentine's Day!
Composer/Lyricist
Some Like It Hot | Smash | Patti LuPone on Broadway | Matters of the Heart | Hairspray | Fame Becomes Me | Catch Me If You Can | SMASH
On the Street Where You Live from My Fair Lady. A valentine to stalkers everywhere. You can just imagine the ski cap and the high powered rifle while you listen to it.
Industry
Author: DIARY OF A SOUTH BEACH PARTY GIRL
"I Have A Love" from WEST SIDE STORY. Commenting on the perfection of the music in this piece--the flow from the strong to the plaintive and the eventual fusing of the two--would require many paragraphs. But the lyrics are equally perfect, particularly when Maria sings, "I love him; I'm his/ And everything he is/ I am too." It always reminds me of the line in WUTHERING HEIGHTS where Catherine says of Heathcliff: "Whatever our souls are made of, his and mine are the same." It isn't about losing one's identity in love; it's about who we love being the ultimate clarifier of who we are.
Creative
Avenue Q
"Somewhere That's Green (reprise)" - It slays me when Audrey tells Seymour to feed her to the plant so that it will grow and bring him all the wonderful things that he desires. Ah, love. It just doesn't get any more romantic than that.
Industry
For me, the most beautiful love song from a Broadway show has to be "My Heart Is So Full Of You" from The Most Happy Fella. I first heard this song sung by the incredible Liz Callaway on the recording "Sibling Revelry", (which, if you don't own, you should go out and buy right now!). I was so taken by the songs' simplistic beauty (and Liz's breathtaking rendition). The song puts forth the notion of loving someone so much that there is no room left in your heart "for anything more...". It's an outrageous concept to anyone with common sense, until they themselves fall in love, and suddenly understand ever word of this beautiful Frank Loesser lullaby.
Performer
Mack & Mabel | War Paint | Living on Love | Little Shop of Horrors | The Scarlet Pimpernel
My favorite love song is "Every Day a Little Death"... no I'm kidding! My favorite is "If I Loved You". I think it's beautiful. It has a sort of negative take- if, if, if... but you know they are crazy about each other in that moment.
Performer
Pippin | A Chorus Line | Sweet Charity | Contact | Chicago | Company | Damn Yankees | Jerome Robbins' Broadway | Carrie | Song and Dance | Cats
"Hey There" from THE PAJAMA GAME. The reason is because I did a production of that show in High School. I was in the chorus and I was madly in love with the guy...and I love the song!
Industry
Triton Gallery
"People" from FUNNY GIRL, sung by the star Barbra Streisand - hands on! I saw FUNNY GIRL in previews and I'll never forget that moment when she sang -- it was an amazing thing!
Performer
The Producers | Hello | Dolly! | Beauty and the Beast | La Cage aux Folles | 42nd Street | Lorelei | Applause | Sweet Charity
I have so many favorites, but the first that comes to mind is "I Only Have Eyes for You." Harry Warren and Al Dubin wrote it for 42ND STREET. It's a wonderful, wonderful song that was in and out of the original show (I know that Dolores Gray sang it at one point), but it was definitely in the arrival. I also love "It Only Takes a Moment" from HELLO, DOLLY! Jerry Herman is my personal favorite!
Performer
Chicago | The Pajama Game | One Mo' Time | Dreamgirls | Ain't Misbehavin'
"Not While I'm Around" because Barbra Streisand sang the fool out of it. It's also such a powerful song about devotion, protection and love.
Performer
Tarzan | Peep Show
"Sun And Moon" from Miss Saigon. The message of this song for me is that love conquers all. No matter who you are, where you are or what you believe, "Sun and Moon" shows us that love is the thing that binds us all together in the end. And what could be more romantic than that!
Performer
Submissions Only | Ordinary Days | Legally Blonde | 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
"Maria" from WEST SIDE STORY! Oh, it kills me!
Performer
La Cage aux Folles | Beauty and the Beast | Seussical | Saturday Night Fever
There are soooo many beautiful romantic Broadway songs that I don't know where to begin! It's a toss up between "I Enjoy Being a Girl," "The Cowman and the Farmer Should be Friends," and "Blow Gabriel Blow." I'm kidding, I'd have to go with "I Got Lost in His Arms". Happy Valentine's Day to all young and old lovers whoever you are.
Performer
La Cage aux Folles | The Producers | Beauty and the Beast | Doonesbury | Annie | 1776
Easy! "Some Enchanted Evening." Because when it's done by the right person with the right voice it transports all of us to that moment when we first spotted someone we found perfect -whether it was in a crowded restaurant or subway. R&H hit emotional heights with this one.
Performer
42nd Street | Romantic Comedy
Oh so many wonderful songs. "Embraceable You," "I Got Lost in His Arms" (Annie Get Your Gun), "My Romance," but the favorite would have to be Irving Berlins "Always." It was sung at Thom and my wedding reception.
Performer
Grease | Funny Girl | Reprise On the 20th Century | Encores! Follies
"Till There Was You" from THE MUSIC MAN is my favorite Broadway love song because it reminds me of when my partner Phil Ford and I were discovered by Jack Paar. I was able to sing it to the world on THE TONIGHT SHOW while reaching for Phil's hand, which brought tears to Jack's eyes, as well as mine. Recording it in 1958 was the icing on the cake!
Director
Good Vibrations | Dance of the Vampires | Into the Woods | Dance of Death | Urinetown | Dirty Blonde | Love! Valour! Compassion! | Singin' in the Rain
After weighing the obvious ("If I Loved You" from CAROUSEL) and the classic ("Tonight" from WEST SIDE STORY)and the sad (there are so many of these including "A Little Fall of Rain" from Les Mis or "Not a Day Goes Boy" from MERRILY) Jessica-Snow Wilson and I both agreed that "I Chose Right" from BABY is probably the song that will always bring tears to our eyes with it's heartfelt lyrics and sentiment. "And I think about you, and I think about me loving you..."
Performer
Paradise Lost | Gypsy | Mystery of Edwin Drood | Romance/Romance | The Secret Garden | Falsettos
Hands down my favorite Broadway love song is “Till There was You” from The Music Man by the great Meredith Willson. To me it is the ultimate musical celebration of the sense of wonder and discovery you feel in the world once your own true love has entered and captured your heart and mind.
Performer
Woman of the Year | Debbie | Irene
"And This is My Beloved" from KISMET because I had such a crush on Alfred Drake.
Performer
PHANTOM- The Las Vegas Spectacular | Princesses | Annie Get Your Gun | Candide | Chicago | Grand Hotel | Dance a Little Closer | West Side Story
"Some Enchanted Evening". It speaks to the irrationality of love, how fleeting it can be, and how you have to dive in, eyes wide shut and trust you heart. Love doesn?t always make sense. If you let your mind take over you can talk yourself out of anything. Happy Valentines Day!
Performer
Death Takes a Holiday | White Christmas. A Chorus Line | The Drowsy Chaperone
"So in Love" from KISS ME, KATE. It breaks my heart and wrenches my stomach every time I hear the words "So taunt me, and hurt me, deceive me, desert me. I'm yours till I die." You may say it's masochistic, but I say it's desperate, undying love (Je t'aime toujours, Aaron)!

Videos


TICKET CENTRAL

Recommended For You