Review: FALLING OUT Turns Chelsea Table + Stage into an Open Mic Confessional

FALLING OUT, a new immersive musical, opened on May 16th at Chelsea Table + Stage, bringing a raw and intimate story into a fully interactive space. With book, music, and lyrics by Josée Klein, direction by Anthony Logan Cole, and production by Weigan-Klein alongside Fidelity Theatricals and Painted Pistachio Productions, the show builds on its earlier run at Frigid NYC this past January. From the start, it’s clear this isn’t just a musical you sit and watch. It’s one you’re placed inside of.

The story centers on Alex, a journalist navigating the aftermath of a breakup while working through therapy. Encouraged to process her emotions more openly, she begins reading from her personal journal at local open mics. That vulnerability takes an unexpected turn when her journal is stolen by Rock, a pop star who was recently released from prison looking for his next reinvention, who uses her words as the foundation for his own music. What unfolds is a layered exploration of ownership, expression, and the blurred lines between personal truth and performance.

The cast, made up of Graceann Kontak, Sam Vana, Emma Gervasi, Emilie Bienne, Austin Karkowsky, and Colum Goebelbecker, is small but incredibly effective. As a group of actor-musicians, they take on the full weight of the storytelling while also providing the live sound of the show. It’s a demanding balance, but one they handle with consistency and clarity, keeping the energy active without losing focus on the characters.

The real standouts of the night were Graceann Kontak and Sam Vana, who carry much of the show as its emotional center. Both performances feel deeply lived in, with a clear understanding of the characters driving every moment. Vocally, there’s a weight to their delivery that never feels forced, allowing the emotion to come through naturally. They manage to anchor the story without overpowering it, creating a dynamic that keeps the narrative moving while still giving space for quieter, more reflective moments.

The immersive aspect of the show is where FALLING OUT really separates itself. The pre-show begins with the cast casually performing as if you’ve walked into the same open mic space the characters inhabit. As the story unfolds, the boundaries between audience and performer continue to dissolve. Scenes move across the entire venue, from the main stage to the bar, through the audience, onto elevated platforms, and even along the staircase leading into the space. It creates a constant sense of motion that pulls you further into the story, making it feel less like you’re watching events unfold and more like you’re inside them.

Musically, the show leans heavily into a rock-inspired sound, with enough variation to keep it from feeling one-note. Because the cast is playing everything live, there’s an immediacy to the music that adds to the authenticity of the piece. It genuinely feels like a band working through something together in real time. Vocally, the entire cast stays locked in, with performances that aren’t afraid to sit in discomfort or vulnerability when the material calls for it.

FALLING OUT ultimately works because it commits fully to both its concept and its storytelling. The immersive staging, the actor-musician format, and the emotional core of the piece all support each other rather than compete. The show is currently running every Saturday and Sunday through May at Chelsea Table + Stage, and it feels like the kind of piece that benefits from being experienced up close, where its intimacy and unpredictability can really land.

2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats

Best Lighting Design - Top 3

1. Jen Schriever, Michael Arden - The Lost Boys

35.1% of votes

2. Jack Knowles - Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)

9.6% of votes

3. Kevin Adams - Chess

7.5% of votes

Vote Now! View Live Stats