Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: THE SUBJECT WAS ROSES at Bay Street Theatre

Performances run through June 16th.

By:
Review: THE SUBJECT WAS ROSES at Bay Street Theatre

Bay Street Theatre's 2024 season kicks off with a thrilling incarnation of Frank D. Gilroy's Pulitzer and Tony-winning play, The Subject Was Roses. Under the masterful direction of Tony, Grammy, and Olivier award-winner Scott Wittman, this promises an enthralling evening. With performances running until June 16th - and if the exciting opening weekend was any indication - you're going to need to get your tickets quickly.

Set in 1946, the play is a heart-tugging exploration of family relationships. Expertly led by the extraordinary performances of Emmy nominee John Slattery (as John Cleary, a salesman), Talia Balsam (as Nettie Cleary), and their son Harry Slattery (as Timmy Cleary), the tale follows the Cleary family's journey. Timmy returns home from World War II but finds he becomes entangled in his parents' unresolved issues, delving deep into themes of love and reconciliation.

What sets this production apart is the authentic portrayal delivered by an actual family. The chemistry and authenticity they bring infuse the show with a profound sense of relatability. From the moments of conflict to the shared laughter, the Cleary family's story mirrors the possible complexities of our own family.

Behind the scenes, the creative team is flawless as they bring 1940s Bronx to life. Derek McLane's stunningly crafted set transports the audience into the heart of the Cleary household. This is complemented by Cha See's atmospheric lighting and Laura Bauer's period-perfect costumes. Marc Shaiman's hauntingly beautiful score further enriches the narrative, elevating the emotional journey of the characters.

And so, The Subject Was Roses is certainly a must-see this beautiful Spring season. With its gripping storyline, stellar cast, and the timeless charm of the Bay Street Theatre, it promises an emotional roller coaster of an evening on the East End of Long Island.



Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Need more Long Island Theatre News in your life?
Sign up for all the news on the Summer season, discounts & more...


BroadwayWorld TV


Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations in Long Island Ain't Too Proud - The Life and Times of The Temptations
The Gateway Performing Arts Center of Suffolk County (6/19-7/19)
THE WEDDING SINGER in Long Island THE WEDDING SINGER
The John W. Engeman Theater (7/09-8/23)
Ann Hampton Callaway - Here's to Life in Long Island Ann Hampton Callaway - Here's to Life
LTV Studios (7/11-7/11)
Urinetown the musical in Long Island Urinetown the musical
South Shore Theatre (7/23-7/23)
I Dream of Broadway in Long Island I Dream of Broadway
Southampton Cultural Center (8/14-8/14)
Annie in Long Island Annie
Herricks Community Theater (10/16-10/25)
Tilles Jazz Fest 2026 in Long Island Tilles Jazz Fest 2026
Tilles Center for the Performing Arts Long Island University (7/18-7/18)
Cabaret in Long Island Cabaret
Theatre Three - NY (9/20-10/25)
I Hate Hamlet by Paul Rudnick in Long Island I Hate Hamlet by Paul Rudnick
South Shore Theatre (8/20-8/20)
Donna McKechnie: A Musical Memoir in Long Island Donna McKechnie: A Musical Memoir
LTV Studios (8/29-8/29)