Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Queer Eye on Horatio Alger

Benjamin's birthday gift to Elliot, a copy of Horatio Alger's juvenile novel Ragged Dick, is an astute choice. Alger's uplifting message that anyone can pull themselves up "by the bootstraps" feels archaic today, but the discovery of Alger's homosexuality, made long after his death, provides relevant insights to the characters of Skintight.

Queer Eye on Horatio Alger
The first edition of "Ragged Dick"
by Horatio Alger (1895)

Horatio Alger Jr. (1832-1899) was one of the most prolific and popular writers of the Gilded Age. His breakthrough Ragged Dick (1867) introduced a uniquely American hero: the poor youth who rises to respectability through hard work, perseverance, and "pluck." The story follows an orphaned shoeshine boy on the streets of New York, as he educates himself and advances in society, with support from some wealthy businessmen who take an interest. Ragged Dick sold so well that Alger recycled the "rags-to-riches" plotline in nearly 100 books. Although never esteemed as a great literary talent, Alger's self-help message impacted generations beyond his own lifetime. (Figures as disparate as Groucho Marx and Ernest Hemingway acknowledged his influence.)

Alger was the youngest son of a respected Unitarian minister in Massachusetts. A sickly but intelligent boy, he aspired to become a writer but also studied religion at Harvard. He briefly held a position as a Unitarian minister, until rumors of sexual activity with teenage boys spread through his congregation. Out of respect for his father's reputation, the church agreed to sweep the scandal under the rug, provided Alger would never again work in the clergy.

Alger fled to New York in 1866. He visited the Newsboys' Lodging House, where he met the homeless boys who inspired his books. At a time when authors did not own copyrights, Alger could earn a modest living, but not a fortune. He supplemented his income tutoring for wealthy families and lived alone, although sometimes in the company of boys he befriended, until his death. In 1972, the discovery of the church scandal and Alger's presumed homosexuality sparked new interest in his work. In his essay, "The Gentle Boy From the Dangerous Classes," Michael Moon interprets the Alger plot as a "particular brand of homoerotic romance as a support for capitalism." Moon identifies the importance of older, wealthy men who take an interest in Alger's young and explicitly good-looking heroes. Moon's reading is an example of the scholarship Benjamin might explore in his queer theory course, and provides a historical lens for considering Elliot's relationship with the much younger Trey.

The relatively young academic field of Queer Studies emerged in the 1970s as an outgrowth of women's studies, African-American studies, and other identity-based fields. Early courses emphasized the hidden history of gay and lesbian lives. Next, "queer theory" emerged in English and literature departments, examining gender as a social construct and sexual identity as a kind of "performance." In the late 1980s, City University of New York and City College of San Francisco created the first departments for LGBTQ studies. Today, many U.S. universities and colleges offer classes, majors, and even graduate degrees in Queer Studies -- with connections to many academic disciplines, including history, biology, philosophy, and social sciences.

Click here to visit Roundabout's blog

Related Stories
Danny DeVito Will Return to Broadway in Theresa Rebecks I NEED THAT Photo
Roundabout Theatre Company has just announced the Broadway and Off-Broadway line-up for the 2023-2024 season. Check out all the details on who, what, when, and where!

Photos: Go Inside the 2023 Roundabout Gala with Sutton Foster & More Photo
Just last night, Roundabout Theatre Company celebrated its 2023 Gala, which featured a very special performance from two-time Tony Award winner Sutton Foster. Check out photos from inside the big night!

Photos: On the Red Carpet for the 2023 Roundabout Gala Photo
Just last night, Roundabout Theatre Company celebrated its 2023 Gala honoring Amy Sherman-Palladino, Daniel Palladino, Scott Ellis, and Black Theatre United. Check out photos from the red carpet!

Photos: Inside Opening Night of THE BANDAGED PLACE Photo
Roundabout Theatre Company just celebrated the 15th anniversary of Roundabout Underground with the world premiere of the bandaged place by Harrison David Rivers, directed by David Mendizábal. BroadwayWorld was there for opening night and you can check out photos from the festivities.

From This Author - Roundabout Theatre Company