Review – ARGUENDO Riffs on the Legality of Public Nudity

Perhaps there's a barrister or two who might experience a bit of a thrill over the current proceedings at the Public's LuEsther Theater, but generally speaking there's nothing that can make even the sensual gyrations of a nightclub stripper lose their sex appeal like reducing it all to judicial procedure and legal jargon.

Review – ARGUENDO Riffs on the Legality of Public NudityAnd that's one of the funnier points of Elevator Repair Service's zany comical piece, Arguendo, a visual farce directed by John Collins that gets its text verbatim from a United States Supreme Court case regarding whether or not Indiana strippers should be forced to wear g-strings and pasties, rather than dance completely nude. (The title is a Latin legal term meaning, "for the sake of argument," used to introduce a point as a matter of illustration.)

Barnes v. Glen Theater, regarding whether or not a public indecency law violated the First Amendment rights of strip club entertainers, climbed up a ladder of lower court decisions and appeals before reaching the highest court in the land in 1991. The dancers claimed that not being allowed to perform fully nude censored their artistic expression, although most of them seemed more concerned with the fact that they made less money while wearing pasties and g-strings. Among other issues, the court had to decide whether or not the act of being nude was a) a form of expression and not just a behavior, and b) an essential element to whatever was being expressed.

A talented company of five (Maggie Hoffman, Mike Iveson, Vin Knight, Susie Sokol and Ben Williams) plays multiple roles, including a dancer who came to listen to the case and the reporters outside the courthouse with pointed questions about her profession. (The text of the scene was taken from a television broadcast.)

Review – ARGUENDO Riffs on the Legality of Public NudityWhile attorneys present their oral arguments, Ben Rubin's animated projections swiftly focus in on legal texts of cases and statutes being mentioned. Three robed actors wheeling around in office chairs cover the entire Scotus 9, who apparently questioned the lawyers giving their oral arguments with bits of dry humor and sarcasm.

When the matter of acceptable public nudity in theatre and opera performances is brought up, Justice Scalia asks about, "the good taste clause of the Constitution." When the Chippewa Book Store is described as an establishment where customers enter private booths to observe nude dancers, Justice Rehnquist queries, "Why do they call this place a book store?"

There's great attention to detail in recreating every pause, stutter and verbal overlap that occurred during oral arguments, and while there was undoubtedly a bit of laughter ringing through the halls of justice that day, Collins and his company broaden up their portrayals to achieve a Marx Brothers-like comedic rebellion. Eventually, a character does wind up completely nude and fully exposed to the audience, but perhaps not in the expected manner.

The 80-minute show is certainly fast and funny, but, like the type of dancing that's the subject of Arguendo, it can be argued that the piece adds no artistic expression to its historic text and that it simply entertains. No matter. I had a swell time.

Photos by Joan Marcus: Top: Susie Sokol, Mike Iveson, Ben Williams and Vin Knight; Bottom: Ben Williams, Maggie Hoffman, Mike Iveson, Susie Sokol, and Vin Knight.

Click here to follow Michael Dale on Twitter.

Related Articles



Comment & Share


About Author

Subscribe to Author Alerts
Michael Dale After 20-odd years singing, dancing and acting in dinner theatres, summer stocks and the ever-popular audience participation murder mysteries (try improvising with audiences after they?ve had two hours of open bar), Michael Dale segued his theatrical ambitions into playwriting. The buildings which once housed the 5 Off-Off Broadway plays he penned have all been destroyed or turned into a Starbucks, but his name remains the answer to the trivia question, "Who wrote the official play of Babe Ruth's 100th Birthday?" He served as Artistic Director for The Play's The Thing Theatre Company, helping to bring free live theatre to underserved communities, and dabbled a bit in stage managing and in directing cabaret shows before answering the call (it was an email, actually) to become BroadwayWorld.com's first Chief Theatre Critic. While not attending shows Michael can be seen at Citi Field pleading for the Mets to stop imploding. Likes: Strong book musicals and ambitious new works. Dislikes: Unprepared celebrities making their stage acting debuts by starring on Broadway and weak bullpens.


BROADWAYWORLD TV