My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

P.J. Benjamin to Reprise Role in CHARLIE AND ALGERNON at Feinstein's/54 Below

By:

As previously announced, the 1980 musical based on the beloved novel Flowers For Algernon will come to life again for one night only at Feinstein's/54 Below. The show's original star, P.J. Benjamin (Wicked, Chicago, Sophisticated Ladies and more), will reprise several of the songs he originated on Broadway 46 years ago this September. He will be joined by his wife Louisa Flaningam (Guys and Dolls, The Most Happy Fella, The Magic Show).

From the team that is bringing ONWARD VICTORIA, Feinstein's/54 Below, comes another wonderful musical with a rarely-heard score. CHARLIE AND ALGERNON features a score by Charles Strouse, the Tony Award-winning composer of Annie, Applause, Rags and Bye, Bye, Birdie with a book and lyrics by David Rogers. The short-lived musical opened on Broadway at The Helen Hayes Theatre on September 14th, 1980 and closed on September 28th, only 17 performances later. It traces the mental and emotional development of Charlie Gordon, a disabled young man who becomes the first human test-subject for an ambitious experiment. Through his friendship with a white mouse named Algernon, we watch Charlie tackle the highs and lows of life.

Over the course of the evening, three different actors will play the title role, charting his progression and regression. In addition to P.J. Benjamin, Be More Chill star George Salazar and 2-time MAC Award-nominee Stearns Matthews will take turns as Charlie. Additional cast members include 7-time MAC Award-winner Natalie Douglas as Lita, Vanessa Spica as Alice Kinnian, Kristen Gehling as Mrs. Donner, Paul Thomas Ryan as Dr. Strauss and Thia Stephan as Charlie's Mom. The show's original Alice, Sandy Faison, will narrate the one-night-only concert. Additional casting will be announced at a later date. The evening is produced and directed by Steven Carl McCasland, with Musical Direction by James Horan.

Tickets are now available at 54below.com/events/charlie-algernon-concert.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Lead Performer in a Play - Top 3
1. Daniel Radcliffe - Every Brilliant Thing
29.4% of votes
2. Nathan Lane - Death of a Salesman
11.9% of votes
3. Ayo Edebiri - Proof
7.3% of votes

Don't Miss a Cabaret News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...


Videos


Claire Kwon: Claire Squared in Cabaret Claire Kwon: Claire Squared
54 Below (5/18-5/18)
When You Wish Upon a Song in Cabaret When You Wish Upon a Song
54 Below (5/22-5/22)
Melba Moore: From Broadway, With Love in Cabaret Melba Moore: From Broadway, With Love
54 Below (6/24-6/24)
Backstage Babble Presents: Broadway’s Future Sings Its Past in Cabaret Backstage Babble Presents: Broadway’s Future Sings Its Past
54 Below (6/26-6/26)
Liberace & Liza: A Tribute in Cabaret Liberace & Liza: A Tribute
54 Below (7/08-7/08)
Melissa Errico: Back to Barbra (with Billy) in Cabaret Melissa Errico: Back to Barbra (with Billy)
54 Below (5/27-5/27)
54 Sings Troye Sivan: A Walk Through Blue Neighborhood in Cabaret 54 Sings Troye Sivan: A Walk Through Blue Neighborhood
54 Below (5/12-5/12)
Madame X- The Musical! by Gerard Alessandrini and Robert Hetzel in Cabaret Madame X- The Musical! by Gerard Alessandrini and Robert Hetzel
54 Below (6/22-6/22)
Lee Roy Reams: My Best of Times with Jerry Herman in Cabaret Lee Roy Reams: My Best of Times with Jerry Herman
54 Below (6/13-6/13)
Bolero Night with Jonathan Lolley in Cabaret Bolero Night with Jonathan Lolley
54 Below (5/14-5/14)