The Wild Party has been nominated for several awards, including Outstanding Choreography (Drama Desk Awards) for Mark Dendy, Outstanding Costume Design (Drama Desk Awards) for Martin Pakledinaz, Outstanding Director - Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for Gabriel Barre, Outstanding Lighting Design (Drama Desk Awards) for Kenneth Posner, Outstanding Lyric (Drama Desk Awards) for Andrew Lippa, Outstanding Music (Drama Desk Awards) for Andrew Lippa, Outstanding New Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for Manhattan Theatre Club, Outstanding Orchestrations (Drama Desk Awards) for Michael Gibson, Outstanding Set Design - Musical (Drama Desk Awards) for David Gallo, Outstanding Choreography (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Mark Dendy, Outstanding Lighting Design (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Kenneth Posner, Outstanding Off-Broadway Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards), Outstanding Scenic Design (The Lortels) for David Gallo, and Performance (Theatre World Awards) for Toni Collette.