My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Review: WHAT IF Ticks All the Boxes at Tandanya Theatre

By:

It is a characteristic of humanity that sets us apart from other species': the ability to imagine alternative worlds, to separate ourselves from instinct and act according to what we dream up. We are frequently taken by the proposition that if we could return to a certain moment in our lives, would we and what would we change. In local creative supernova Mahalia Barr-Mashei's latest offering at the Adelaide Fringe Festival, 'What If', a genesis of music, dance and drama twists around the concept of going back in time to change the course of fate.

The strength of the production was in the vocals of duo-ingénues Barr-Mashei and Kelly O'Brien, the talents of dancers Mieke Kriegesvelt, Felicity Boyd and Larissa Simpson, and the potent film that set the scene. Very few productions endeavour to present original music as this one did, all composed by Justin Pounsett and genuinely enjoyable as punctuation for the show's strong emotional backbone. 'What If' did not shy from triggering content, but did so responsibly with consideration for its audience and the realities of loss and trauma. A resonant message told creatively and powerfully, with local performers worth keeping an eye on year round.

Reader Reviews

To post a comment, you must register and login.

Theater Fans' Choice Awards
2026 Theater Fans' Choice Awards - Live Stats
Best Revival of a Musical - Top 3
1. Ragtime
38.9% of votes
2. CATS: The Jellicle Ball
22.4% of votes
3. Chess
21.9% of votes

Don't Miss a Australia - Adelaide News Story
Sign up for all the news on the Spring season, discounts & more...

Local Shows
MACHINAL in Australia - Adelaide MACHINAL
Goodwood Theatre & Studios (5/21-5/30)
The Heartbreak Choir in Australia - Adelaide The Heartbreak Choir
State Theatre Company South Australia (11/20-12/05)
Faulty Towers The Dining Experience - Darwin in Australia - Adelaide Faulty Towers The Dining Experience - Darwin
Oaks Elan Darwin (8/20-8/22)
Uncle Vanya - but there’s ASMR soap cutting videos playing in the bottom right corner in Australia - Adelaide Uncle Vanya - but there’s ASMR soap cutting videos playing in the bottom right corner
State Theatre Company South Australia (7/09-7/18)
Faulty Towers The Dining Experience - Adelaide in Australia - Adelaide Faulty Towers The Dining Experience - Adelaide
Adelaide Royal Coach (6/20-6/20)
Boogie Wonderland in Australia - Adelaide Boogie Wonderland
Adelaide Royal Coach (7/10-7/12)
The Importance of Being Earnest in Australia - Adelaide The Importance of Being Earnest
State Theatre Company South Australia (5/08-5/30)
LOGAN ST in Australia - Adelaide LOGAN ST
State Theatre Company South Australia (7/24-8/08)
The Heartbreak Choir in Australia - Adelaide The Heartbreak Choir
State Theatre Company South Australia (11/20-12/05)
Commentary in Australia - Adelaide Commentary
State Theatre Company South Australia (8/21-9/05)


Videos