Shows at the Fifth Avenue Theatre |
| DATES |
PRODUCTION |
| 11/5/1935 | - | | Bertha, the Sewing Machine Girl (1935) |
| 1/13/1926 | - | | The House of Ussher (1926) |
| 12/16/1925 | - | | The Wisecrackers (1925) |
| 5/16/1912 | - | | The Great Game (1912) |
| 1/10/1910 | - | 1/22/1910 | The King of Cadonia (1910) |
| 4/22/1907 | - | | The Jungle (1907) |
| 4/23/1906 | - | | Jeanne D'arc (1906) |
| 11/13/1905 | - | | Oliver Twist (1905) |
| 8/14/1905 | - | | Zorah (1905) |
| 3/27/1905 | - | | Anna Karenina (1905) |
| 1/30/1905 | - | | The Holy City (1905) |
| 6/13/1904 | - | | Fighting Bob (1904) |
| 3/7/1904 | - | | Hush-a-Bye Baby (1904) |
| 5/11/1903 | - | | Who Is Brown? (1903) |
| 4/6/1903 | - | | A Modern Crusoe (1903) |
| 3/19/1900 | - | | Oliver Goldsmith (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | Twelfth Night (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | Much Ado About Nothing (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | Mary Stuart (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | Marie Antoinette (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | The Ladies' Battle (1900) |
| 2/26/1900 | - | | Macbeth (1900) |
| 2/6/1900 | - | | The Countess Chiffon (1900) |
| 12/25/1899 | - | 2/3/1899 | Three Little Lambs (1899) |
| 9/12/1899 | - | | Becky Sharp (1899) |
| 5/11/1899 | - | 6/17/1899 | The Charlatan (1889) |
| 4/11/1899 | - | | Citizen Pierre (1899) |
| 11/21/1898 | - | 2/25/1899 | A Runaway Girl (1898) |
| 10/3/1898 | - | | The Royal Box (1898) |
| 4/11/1898 | - | | A Bit of Old Chelsea (1898) |
| 4/11/1898 | - | | Love Finds the Way (1898) |
| 3/30/1898 | - | | Hedda Gabler (1898) |
| 1/29/1898 | - | | Joan (1898) |
| 12/21/1897 | - | | The Royal Box (1897) |
| 11/29/1897 | - | | Alexandra (1897) |
| 10/4/1897 | - | | The Devil's Disciple (1897) |
| 9/4/1897 | - | | A Southern Romance (1897) |
| 5/7/1897 | - | | Divorcons (1897) |
| 2/1/1897 | - | | Dr. Claudius (1897) |
| 1/4/1897 | - | | A Superfluous Husband (1897) |
| 4/18/1896 | - | | The Speculator (1896) |
| 3/23/1896 | - | | A House of Cards (1896) |
| 3/19/1896 | - | 3/19/1896 | Pamela Nubile (1896) |
| 1/21/1896 | - | | The Governor of Kentucky (1896) |
| 10/22/1895 | - | | Ambition (1895) |
| 6/3/1895 | - | | For Fair Virginia (1895) |
| 2/25/1895 | - | | His Wife's Father (1895) |
| 12/11/1894 | - | | Gismonda (1894) |
| 11/12/1894 | - | | The Coming Woman (1894) |
| 5/1/1894 | - | | Hannele (1894) |
| 1/26/1893 | - | | The Moth and the Flame (1893) |
| 12/8/1890 | - | | Joan of Arc (1890) |
| 9/21/1887 | - | 12/10/1887 | The Begum (1887) |
| 2/21/1887 | - | 4/9/1887 | Ruddigore (1887) |
| 8/20/1885 | - | | The Mikado (1885) |
| 2/11/1884 | - | 3/22/1884 | Princess Ida (1884) |
| 12/31/1879 | - | | The Pirates of Penzance (1879) |
| 4/14/1879 | - | | Fatinitza (1879) |
| 10/22/1877 | - | 11/10/1877 | The Chimes of Normandy (1877) |
| 3/28/1871 | - | | Jezebel (1871) |
| - | | King Richard II () |
