When The Rain Stops Falling has won several awards for its outstanding contributions in various categories. These include the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Sound Design in a Play, which was awarded to Fitz Patton. David Cromer received the Lortel Award for Outstanding Director, while Tyler Micoleau was recognized with the Lortel Award for Outstanding Lighting Design. The play itself, produced by Lincoln Center Theater, won the Lortel Award for Outstanding Play. Additionally, David Korins received the Lortel Award for Outstanding Scenic Design, and Fitz Patton was honored again with the Lortel Award for Outstanding Sound Design.