The Petrified Prince has been nominated for several awards. These include Outstanding Costume Design at the Drama Desk Awards for Jane Greenwood and Sylvia, Outstanding Set Design at the Drama Desk Awards for James Youmans, Outstanding Costume Design at The Lortels for Judith Dolan, and Outstanding Costume Design at the Drama Desk Awards again for Judith Dolan. Additionally, the show received another nomination for Outstanding Set Design at the Drama Desk Awards for James Youmans.