Newyorkers has won several awards for its outstanding performances. The show received the Outstanding Musical Revue award at the Drama Desk Awards. Pamela Isaacs, a performer in the production, was recognized with the Performance award at the Obie Awards. Additionally, Newyorkers won the Outstanding Off-Broadway Musical award at the Outer Critics Circle Awards. Daniel Pelzig, the choreographer for the show, received the Outstanding Choreographer award at The Lortels. Lastly, the Manhattan Theatre Club, which produced Newyorkers, was honored with the Outstanding Musical award at The Lortels.
