Fantasia as Effie, I THINK NOT- Page 5

[firecracker]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:03pm

Laurence Fishburne got his start on The Pee Wee Herman Show playing a corny ass cowboy. American Idol should be irrelevant at this point.

[GhettoBway]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:15pm

um no he didnt he was a child star his first show was "One Life to live"

[firecracker]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:33pm

Point is, he was STILL on that corny laughable piece of **** show.

[jaso_n]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:37pm

Like Marquise said way upthread, Fantasia is a very talented singer and performer, but her vocal type is wrong for Effie. It's fine that we're past the big girl thing, but this is Dreamgirls. Jennifer Holliday was cast for a couple of reasons -- one of them being that she was overweight. Now lets be for real. In the movie adaptation, she needs to be a heavy set girl with a huge, sweeping, Gospel voice. That's not Fantasia.

But whatever. I'll go see it no matter who they have in it.

[JoMarch]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:42pm

Fantasia isn't exactly stick thin. If she gained about 10-15 pounds, it might work. Plus, she doesn't have the drop dead looks of the other two women cast. Maybe they could use her looks as a downfall instead of her weight. I don't like her voice though.

[Thetruth]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:55pm

Since my presence was requested in this thread, I decided to oblige my haters.

Kuhn, I have never assured anyone that Fantasia would get the role of Effie. I have always prefaced anything I said about her getting the role was a rumor. You might be illiterate b/c if you actually read all of my posts you would know that I wanted her for Lorell. I havn't counted her out as Effie b/c I'm actually interested in what her interpretation will be. All I want is the best Effie. If that's Fantasia then so be it.

As far as "her people" go...What would be the point of people spreading that she did well on her screen test if she wasn't in the running. That would make her look bad to the producers of the movie. Also, Jamie Foxx is not exactly in her camp. He is on her record label, so someone might see an angle there. I actually think the makers of the film are spreading these rumors b/c they are unsure of Fantasia b/c of her film experienceand want to see what people's reactions will are.

It's already been established that Fantasia is generally hated on these boards. She's not a "pure voice," which is what broadway folks are more partial to. I can't believe anyone would compare her to Ciara as an indicator of anything. Britney Spears has sold more than Aretha...SO?

Whether you like it or not Fantasia is straight up "church" and is definitly one of the new premiere soul singers. She possesses a lot of the qualities required for the role.


Just by the debate on this topic (it's funny b/c there's such strong hate and love for her), it's obvious that if she gets the role, Fantasia's performance will be one that folks will be talking about.

[ljay889]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 7:59pm

HATE is a VERY VERY VERY strong thing.

I don't think it's right label those who aren't fond of Fantasia as HATERS. Not fair at all. The word has a very strong meaning.

Posted: 11/1/05 at 8:58pm

"Since my presence was requested in this thread, I decided to oblige my haters."

Your prescence wasn't requested, it was expected. And no one hates you. Quit being so dramatic.

"As far as "her people" go...What would be the point of people spreading that she did well on her screen test if she wasn't in the running. I actually think the makers of the film are spreading these rumors b/c they are unsure of Fantasia b/c of her film experienc and want to see what people's reactions will are."

If they makers of the film are indeed speading these rumors (and I seriously doubt they're that stupid) then the movie is in very shaky hands. Competent filmmakers know whether or not an "actress" is capable of a performance without having to run to the Internet and gauge the common's man's opinion, especially when the common man hasn't even seen her screen test. Not to mention, they'd be wasting a large amount of studio money giving screen tests to women who aren't even in the running. Ridiculous theory.

"You might be illiterate b/c if you actually read all of my posts you would know that I wanted her for Lorell."

1) Ah, there you go. The typical personal insults slung from Team Fantasia anytime they hear something they don't like. Real mature.

2) As far as being illiterate, no, can't go there, it's just too easy...

[ljay889]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 9:05pm

LOL. "Team Fantasia."

Anyway - THETRUH always tries to make Fantasia out to be better than she actually is. New premiere soul singer? right!

Fantie tries to hard to be the next Mary J. Blige which isn't happening. She will NEVER bring out the raw emotion in a song like Blige does and is known for.

Fantasia might sell platinum but that dosen't make her talented. I've said it before. But true talents like Faith Evans, Vivian Green, Tamia, Monica, etc blow her out of the water. OH! And those ladies can actually sing a melody!!
Updated On: 11/1/05 at 09:05 PM

[Thetruth]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 9:20pm

>>>Your prescence wasn't requested, it was expected. And no one hates you. Quit being so dramatic. >>>


"Haters" or "hating" is a slang term. Ask somebody about it. You typed my name. You had me on your brain. I've never even seen or heard of you before.

>>>>If they makers of the film are indeed speading these rumors (and I seriously doubt they're that stupid) then the movie is in very shaky hands. Competent filmmakers know whether or not an "actress" is capable of a performance without having to run to the Internet and gauge the common's man's opinion, especially when the common man hasn't even seen her screen test. Not to mention, they'd be wasting a large amount of studio money giving screen tests to women who aren't even in the running. Ridiculous theory. >>>>

Well, Condon and Geffen have proven themselves, so if Fantasia has been chosen for the role will keep it closed? And who said anything about them running to the internet. News about Fantasia has been on Access Hollywood/ET and in the papers. This is not just a message board thing. And you bring up an excellent point about not having seen her screen test. So, how could you have the nerve to speak about her in this role. Get ouf ot the thread. Jamie Foxx is in a much better position to judge how Fantasia's screentest went (most likely he's seen it)than we are. Obviously, there's a hold up, for him to push for her like that in the media. And don't discount message boards, b/c there are "high up" folks who do read them.


>>>>1) Ah, there you go. The typical personal insults slung from Team Fantasia anytime they hear something they don't like. Real mature. <<<<<<<

Again, what puts me on Team Fantasia? Just b/c I think the girl deserves a chance? You said it yourself, no one here has seen her screen test.

Posted: 11/1/05 at 9:27pm

"And you bring up an excellent point about not having seen her screen test. So, how could you have the nerve to speak about her in this role. Get ouf ot the thread."

Well you heard it, folks, If you haven't seen Fantasia's screen test, you're not allowed to post on this thread. Clear out, Everyone! Last one out, turn out the lights!

"And don't discount message boards, b/c there are "high up" folks who do read them."

No sh*t, Sherlock. That's what I've been saying all along. I really feel all this obnoxious hype will backfire on her.

[Thetruth]

Posted: 11/1/05 at 11:35pm

>Well you heard it, folks, If you haven't seen Fantasia's screen test, you're not allowed to post on this thread. Clear out, Everyone! Last one out, turn out the lights! <<<<

No, I'm telling you to get out by using your own words against you. Your words apply to you, not everybody else.

>>>No sh*t, Sherlock. That's what I've been saying all along. I really feel all this obnoxious hype will backfire on her. >>>>

You need to pick a side and stick to it. First, you say they don't read message boards now you say they do. I'm over and done with you.

Posted: 11/1/05 at 11:58pm

"You need to pick a side and stick to it. First, you say they don't read message boards now you say they do. I'm over and done with you."

Uh, I said no such thing. I said the film makers don't need to run to the Internet for the common man's opinion when it comes to their casting decisions. I never said they didn't read message boards. Stop making crap up because you're too emotional and close to this matter to read clearly.

[jimmirae]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 12:30am

Queen Latifah would make an excellent Effie!

[Thetruth]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 12:37am

Kuhn, what are you still doing on here? The library closed at 9.

[jimmirae]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 12:43am

I suppose I should say as well that I like "Effie" with some weight on those bones as well, It just plays better that way when she is asked to step aside for DJ., I KNOW Effie is pregnant, But it has mor impact when she has the "Big Momma" look as well, IMHO.

Posted: 11/2/05 at 12:56am

"Kuhn, what are you still doing on here? The library closed at 9."

Well I know you can't be talking to me because you said you were done with me and you always tell The Truth.

[BSoBW2]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 12:58am

The Truth is Subjective.

Posted: 11/2/05 at 1:01am

Understatement of the year.

But that's what happens when someone else signs your checks.

[Tallulabelle]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 4:10am

"I wonder what everyone would be saying if Fantasia WASN'T on AI and was discovered during the search for Effie as an "unknown"?"

Considering Clive Davis had to PAY for Fantasia to audition, I think the answer is, "Nothing," only because she never would have been able to even get her foot in the door.

When you think about it, that's probably all this is, just like the controversy over "Baby Mama" only for the song not to be released as a single, and just like the controversy over her being "illiterate" only for her to turn around two days later and say she was the victim of bad editing, when editing can't put the words, "I couldn't get a job because I couldn't read and I couldn't count money," in someone's mouth.

Clive Davis manufactures buzz about his Precious in continually futile attempts to kick Fantasia's album sales into high gear. Paying for her "Dreamgirls" audition and then spreading the news about her perpetually-"imminent" casting around is just one of those attempts.

And before one of her cult members throws her sales figures in my face, for someone with so many supposed "MEGA R&B HITZ," and getting rave reviews opening for Kanye West, her album didn't live up to the hype and is, and seems like it will stay, completely off the radar no matter HOW much money Clive throws away on her.

Too bad. That payola and spin doctor money could have been put to much better use. Like lighting it on fire or flushing it down the toilet. Or perhaps teaching Fantasia that "conversate" and "pianoist" are not real words.
Updated On: 11/2/05 at 04:10 AM

[Interested Bystander]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 9:27am

Whoa, this thread is pretty hot. Well, if none of the AI ladies, including Jennifer Hudson, hadn't been on the show, then I guess none of them would have gotten a shot at auditioning.

I doubt very seriously that the internet bickering of the yea and naysayers will have any impact on the casting of this role. What it shows is the intense emotion that Fantasia's name brings out it folks -- and that can only help the movie. Because if Fantasia is cast, then despite what some people have pronounced, folks will come see the movie. Some will come because they love her and others will come because they dislike her and want to see her fail.

Casting against public perception is nothing new and has had varied results. For example: Diana Ross in "Lady Sings the Blues" and in the "Wiz." Madonna in "Evita" and your girl Renee Zellweger in "Chicago."

Since when did Clive pay for Fantasia's audition? That is something I hadn't heard before but I am open to a show of proof.

On a side note, the whole report card thing still doesn't explain why Beyonce referred to the group as a "treesome."
Updated On: 11/2/05 at 09:27 AM

[Tallulabelle]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 9:38am

"Since when did Clive pay for Fantasia's audition? That is something I hadn't heard before but I am open to a show of proof."

Sorry, I don't have proof but I've seen her fans bragging about it at length, as if that's a GOOD thing, so I assumed there was something concrete to give them this idea.

[Interested Bystander]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 9:45am

Oh, you are talking about the whole Denzel coaching her for a private screen test paid for by Clive rumour. That's not the same thing as paying Condon for an official screen test. As rumours go, it sure was interesting, but unconfirmed.

[aikaire3]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 9:48am

I definately think Fantasia is a great choice for this role, and more so than J. Hudson though she is a good singer. When you carry on a role you should be able to capture the original feeling of that character but bring your own passion to it vocally and acting wise. Fantasia has soul grit and a great voice and from what the director said she can ACT!!! I cant wait to see shawdy tear into that role and that roles signature song!


Go head with you bad self Fantasia!!!!!

[Rams4ever]

Posted: 11/2/05 at 10:30am

Fantasia is perhaps the most appropriate singing actress for this role.

Let us remember that this is a big screen production. This is not some small time, cheesy, sleazy Broadway production. Broadway in its current state has declined dramatically from the original music theater days of Ellington, Kern, Gershwin, Berlin et al.

Effie needs a singing-actress with a huge personality for portrayal on the big screen. Super-talented vocally, sexy and infectious personality Fantasia came along at precisely the right time to enliven Effie as has never before been accomplished!

Sell me a ticket right now.