I love the idea of Groban as the Beast. If he was willing to play the secondary lead in a show as unconventional as Great Comet, I think he’d be game to do this. I also agree that Laura Osnes would be great as Belle, even if she is the obvious choice. The idea of Denee Benton and Hailey Kilgore as Belle is also exciting. I also feel like Ethan Slater could make for a very fun Lumiere. At the same time I think he’d be a perfect Lefou, but the role is probably too small for him. I may not have made it clear in my first post about the possibility of Timothy Hughs as Gaston, not only do I think that could very likely happen(so long as they don’t mind having a smaller name), but I think it would be a fantastic choice
Mark S Hoebee, who was in the first production is directing it at papermill, he also directed newsies and a lot of other papermill shows. It might be the papermill production?
Rachel Zelger for Belle! She even tweeted she would love to be casted. I would love for somebody around 18-25 to play Belle. Anybody older just sometimes looks out of place up there.
asoftplacetoland said: "Rachel Zelger for Belle! She even tweeted she would love to be casted. I would love for somebody around 18-25 to play Belle. Anybody older just sometimes looks out of place up there."
I don;t want to be ageist, but I think that Disney princess stars should be in the 18-25 range. When you cast middle-aged women like Patti Murin and Caissie Levy as characters half their age, it just feels a bit awkward...
And yes, I know Kristen Bell and Idina Menzel are also much older than Anna and Elsa, but there is a world of difference between voicing the characters and playing them on stage 8 times a week...
I kind of hope they do some bizarre, radical reinterpretation of this musical. Saw the the recent tour, and it was really awful. Hopefully, they can find something interesting to do with this that doesn't just feel like a theme park show.
Laura would be such a snooze fest in this role, and the trend of casting the typical ingenues in the regional market for this show over these last few years drives me crazy.
I think a lot of people were surprised at her performance opposite Steven Pasquale in the Chicago Lyric Opera production of Carousel. It would be a terrible career move playing another Disney princess, but I guess young actresses don't turn down too many starring roles.
I like the fresh young face option.
Who knew back when The Mickey Mouse Club was ruling the airwaves and we were having our Mickey Mouse themed birthday parties wearing our Mickey Mouse ears that Disney one day would be such a force on Broadway. Is Star Trek next? That franchise has been around almost as long as Disney and its most recognized star, Patrick Stuart, will soon return to the role of Jean Luc Picard in a new television series.
JennH said: "Conclusion- I'm down only if they don't model it after the live action film and castfresh faces for this. There's NO reason to not do so. NONE."
Given how financially successful the film was, I'm assuming they want to carry something from the movie over into any possible revival. But I don't know what that would look like because you can't CGI something for the stage (well, projections but ew). Puppets is interesting. Something in between the cartoonish look of the original and what they've done with Lion King, Sven in Frozen, etc. It would probably be too costly and time-consuming but I'd be interested to see what the show would look like with either specific effects makeup or minimal makeup and intense costuming. At this point people know the characters. So maybe Mrs. Potts can just be an actress in a voluminous dress and the audience can imagine she's a teapot. Like, the Disney Dream version but without them having to hold the puppets/objects.
^^ About the puppet idea...a good few regional theaters have done it before that travesty of a cruise line production and there's something about it I do not like...it comes off as odd and I'm still deciding why that is. Someone else said it's because life size teapots and candles don't read to the back of the theater. I also wonder if it's because it just reads as strangely abstract in a show that was conceived as pretty darn NON abstract. Lion King was conceived in abstract hence why it works. And that's a whole new level of puppetry, it's not just a cute little hand worked device, they're literally working an entire body apparatus in that show...
Jordan Catalano said: "Christy Altomare would be a lovely Belle, but I’m not sure if she’d want to play another role like that."
I could live with this...nor could I imagine her saying no to this either. She VERY much a princess type but there something about her that's still different that the usual princess type that sets her apart. She's not totally homogenous ( like Laura) but she's too far out of the mold either...
Oh if Gavin is Lumiere at Papermill I NEED to see it...
Thank you for posting this! I just bought my ticket. Last 10 min is where he discusses Paper Mill. I wonder if this was recorded before the revival was announced.
I am so excited! Beauty and the Beast is literally my favorite animated Disney movie and ever since it closed on Broadway, I have been waiting for a revival! I have already dreamcasted the show and some members for the creative team as well...
Belle: Laura Osnes (it's her dream role and she ageless tbh), Hailey Kilgore OR Kara Lindsay
Beast: Jeremy Jordan, Josh Groban OR Aaron Tviet
Gaston: Ben Thompson
LeFou: Andrew Keenan-Bolger
Maurice: Joel Grey
Lumiere: Gavin Creel OR Gabriel Ebert
Cogsworth: Brooks Ashmanskas
Mrs. Potts: Audra McDonald
Director: Bartlett Sher, Kathleen Marshall OR Michael Arden