Having seen both, definitely Alice by Heart. Both shows are flawed, but at least Alice by Heart has very creative staging, and a (slightly) better score. Superhero is one boring ballad after another with no convincing character development. It was the worst experience during my February trip to New York.
lachri5 said: "Having seen both, definitely Alice by Heart. Both shows are flawed, but at least Alice by Heart has very creative staging, and a (slightly) better score. Superhero isone boring ballad after another with no convincing character development. It was the worst experience during my February trip to New York."
I don’t regret seeing Superhero (didn’t see Alice), but despite a talented cast (lead by the great Kate Baldwin), it was my least favorite of my seven shows on my trip last month. So I have to ask, why are these your only two choices?
I can't speak on Superhero but I've seen Alice 6 times and I adore it. The audiences have been mixed throughout previews but I went last night and the audience seemed to really enjoy