Just curious if there are any people on here that watch the Oscar religiously and find certain performances completely unworthy of an acting award. I know that when I saw "Sunset Boulevard", (quite awhile after it came out), I certainly thought that Gloria Swanson had won the Oscar that year for Best Actress. Imagine my surprise to find out that Bette Davis was also nominated that year for "All About Eve", but they both lost to Judy Holiday for "Born Yesterday". I have a lot to add to my list including Halle Berry, Cuba Gooding, Jr. among others...
William Hurt in Kiss of the Spiderwoman. Never bought him as a fem gay man and couldn’t see how his portrayal was so lauded. Thought Raul Julia was perfect.
There are a lot. I feel like all four of the Oscar winners this year are going to be an example of this. Especially, Regina King who has somehow become the frontrunner for supporting actress even though she doesn't do anything award worthy in Beale Street. I feel like Glenn Close really doesn't do anything particularly impressive in The Wife, especially considering she's given several far superior performances in her lifetime. Rami Malek is never believable as Freddie Mercury and Mahershala Ali doesn't do anything impressive enough to justify getting a second Academy Award within two years of his first win. I think all four are completely forgettable performances that will fade away.
GeorgeandDot said: "There are a lot. I feel like all four of the Oscar winners this year are going to be an example of this. Especially, Regina King who has somehow become the frontrunner for supporting actress even though she doesn't do anything award worthy in Beale Street. I feel like Glenn Close really doesn't do anything particularly impressive in The Wife, especially considering she's given several far superior performances in her lifetime. Rami Malek is never believable as Freddie Mercury and Mahershala Ali doesn't do anything impressive enough to justify getting a second Academy Award within two years of his first win. I think all four are completely forgettable performances that will fade away."
I’m with you there (though I may have more affection for Close’s performance than you and wouldn’t hate for King to win because I adored Beale Street so much). Ideally, they’d just give Oscars to Olivia Coleman, Emma Stone and Rachel Weisz and call it a day.
After seeing Malek make the rounds, I fail to see the “transformation” so many raved about; I just see Malek with a British accent and horribly distracting fake teeth. And Ali is fine in a terrible movie, I much prefer Grant’s delightfully droll performance in Can You Ever Forgive Me.
Frank Sinatra - From Here to Eternity Elizabeth Taylor - Butterfield 8 Ingrid Bergman - Murder on the Orient Express Faye Dunaway - Network Jessica Lange - Tootsie Don Amece - Cocoon Michael Douglas - Wall Street Dustin Hoffman - Rain Man Joe Pesci - Good Fellas Kim Basinger - L.A. Confidential Angelina Jolie - Girl, Interrupted Denzel Washington - Training Day Jennifer Connelly - A Beautiful Mind Hillary Swank - Million Dollar Baby Alan Arkin - Little Miss Sunshine Christian Bale - The Fighter Leonardo DiCaprio - The Revenant Gary Oldan - Darkest Hour
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian
GeorgeandDot said: "There are a lot. I feel like all four of the Oscar winners this year are going to be an example of this. Especially, Regina King who has somehow become the frontrunner for supporting actress even though she doesn't do anything award worthy in Beale Street. I feel like Glenn Close really doesn't do anything particularly impressive in The Wife, especially considering she's given several far superior performances in her lifetime. Rami Malek is never believable as Freddie Mercury and Mahershala Ali doesn't do anything impressive enough to justify getting a second Academy Award within two years of his first win. I think all four are completely forgettable performances that will fade away."
Boy, are you tough. IMO, Glenn Close is giving the best performance of her movie career after Jenny Fields. Clearly, the role is not a showy one, but I believed every nuance, glance, etc.; then, when she exploded, she proved she can explode with the best of them. The thing I love about Close is her ability to do totally over the top believably, e.g., Sunset Blvd. or Fatal Attraction, which I otherwise hated; and then go the opposite extreme and give such a quiet performance. Again, IMO, I think Ali and King were both outstanding in their roles...I would definitely vote for Ali, were I a member of the academy, and either Amy Adams or King in their category, which is incredibly strong, especially when you consider some of the performances not nominated, e.g., Nicole Kidman and Claire Foy, to name two off the top of my head.
Re my response to the subject, I think there are certain performances that were 'of their time', i.e., pretty overacted when that was okay, e.g., Susan Hayward 'I Want to Live' or Elizabeth Taylor in her 'I'm Not Dead Yet' Butterfield 8 performance. I also know that it was a consolation prize, but Julie Andrews' Oscar has always been positively absurd to me. Also, Jessica Lange for Big Sky, which is right up there as the worst year ever for actresses. In terms of 'can't stand, I would have to go with Jessica Lange, who I otherwise like a lot.
Re actors, there is a tie between Jean Dujardin in The Artist, a movie about which I loathed everything except Berenice Bejo; and Al Pacino, already in his chew up the scenery phase for his consolation prize for Scent of a Woman.
For supporting actress, in what is probably the most overacted performance ever, Katina Paxinou for For Whom the Bell Tolls.
Finally, supporting actor, there is no performance I cant stand, although I think a couple of the wins were ridiculous, e.g., Don Ameche
In the case of Jessica Lange, who I am a HUGE fan of, I can't understand how a film that was three years old could compete at the Oscars against films that came out that year. The film didn't look that good from the clips that I saw and couldn't see why it won. I really wish the Ellen Burstyn had won for "Requiem for a Dream", Edward Norton had won for "Primal Fear" and Peter O'Toole had won for "Venus".
Jarethan, I really disagree that this is Glenn's greatest performance. Yes, she is very nuanced here, but there are several moments that ring false to me in her performance. I think it's largely due to the writing and weak supporting cast, but, honestly, I just don't think it's the best performance in the category. It's a great performance, but they're all great performances (except Yalitza who just rode her way to a nomination on the coattails of Roma). I think Colmam really gives a downright incredible performance in The Favourite. The work she does in that film is remarkable and she's at the top of her game here. I really want Close to win an Oscar, but I just don't think this is an Oscar winning performance. Same for Gaga. I'm a big Lady Gaga fan, but I just don't think she gives an Oscar worthy performance.
Sorry to make this so long, but I thought I would dig deeper into some of the other categories real quick. My problem with both Regina King and Amy Adams is the same problem I have with Close, they would be winning because they're overdue, which all three are, but not necessarily for the quality of their performances. I mean Adams and King are both wonderful in their films, but neither are Oscar worthy performances. They both have limited screen time and I feel like Emma Stone, Rachel Weisz, and Marina all give superior performances. Ali is wonderful in Green Book (a film I didn't care for), but Richard E. Grant gives a better performance. I'm not saying anyone is bad at all when I say they shouldn't win, I'm just saying that I think someone else in their category is giving a better performance.
I personally would have voted for either Teri Garr or Lesley Ann Warren. However, Lange really does do lovely work in Tootsie and she was unbelievable in FRANCES that same year. In any other year she would have won for that...but no one was going to beat Streep for SOPHIE'S CHOICE. So I can't get mad at this one.
But...let's talk about that awful Helen Hunt woman.
SonofRobbieJ said: "I personally would have voted for either Teri Garr or Lesley Ann Warren. However, Lange really does do lovely work in Tootsie and she was unbelievable in FRANCES that same year. In any other year she would have won for that...but no one was going to beat Streep for SOPHIE'S CHOICE. So I can't get mad at this one.
But...let's talk about that awful Helen Hunt woman."
I can't complain. TOOTSIE is one of the greatest movies of all time-- I just wish the Academy would have awarded the comedic supporting role, which I think is much more difficult to pull off.
Have to disagree about Helen Hunt. I adore that performance. I also think it's a great example of the script aiding the performance. As opposed to Kate Winslet in TITANIC where the script went out of its way to hinder her.
Kevin Spacey. In anything. Ever. But especially when he picked up two of the least deserved Oscars in Academy history.
Otherwise, there's DiCaprio winning Best Actor for breathing heavily and crawling through snow in THE REVENANT.
"If they can get you asking the wrong questions, they don't have to worry about the answers." Thomas Pynchon, GRAVITY'S RAINBOW
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away." Philip K. Dick
My blog: http://www.roscoewrites.blogspot.com/
I hate everything about As Good As It Gets. Everything. And I stopped liking Helen Hunt somewhere around the 2nd season of Mad About You. Though I adore her in Girls Just Want to Have Fun.
Plus...she beat Judi Dench in Mrs. Brown, Julie Christie in Afterglow and and bloody Helena Bonham Carter for Wings of the Dove! Come ON!
I also intensely dislike Titanic. I mean...I know why it won...but L.A. Confidential is a far superior film.
In our millions, in our billions, we are most powerful when we stand together. TW4C unwaveringly joins the worldwide masses, for we know our liberation is inseparably bound.
Signed,
Theater Workers for a Ceasefire
https://theaterworkersforaceasefire.com/statement