Mean Girls vs. Once on this Island

[broadwayboundck]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 1:35pm

Question for those who have seen both Mean Girls and Once on this Island: which one did you like better and why? I only have room for one and cannot decide!

[Impossible2]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 1:43pm

I enjoyed both experiences about the same, but I would give OOTI a slighter edge simply because it was original material and the production itself was innovative and exciting.

Mean Girls is flashy mindless entertainment and a fairly decent representation of a far better work, ie the film.

[GeorgeandDot]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 1:43pm

Once on this Island is way better. It's a magical production with a ton of incredible talent. I didn't particularly like Mean Girls. It's a downgrade from the film and is a very mediocre musical in basically every aspect.

[Wildcard]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:05pm

Mean Girls on tour will appear much like the Broadway Production. Once on This Island can only be experienced in NY in its current iteration. 

[jbp1232]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:05pm

Once on this Island hands down. I really enjoyed Mean Girls and had a great time, but Once on this Island is truly special. The production is really unique and original and the one act show flies by.

[jbp1232]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:07pm

Wildcard said: "Mean Girls on tour will appear much like the Broadway Production. Once on This Island can only be experienced in NY in its current iteration."

THIS. I can’t imagine what a tour of OOTI would look like, but there will uncountable modifications. Mean Girls will likely be a replica. 

[South Fl Marc]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:09pm

I agree with everyone - go see "Once On This Island".

"Mean Girls" won't lose anything when it tours even in the mostly too large touring venues. OOTI , on the other hand, is in a unique space and must be seen in NYC.

[Bwayfan292]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:13pm

Once on this island.

[suicidalmickeymouse]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:18pm

Once on This Oslanf, hands down.

[suicidalmickeymouse]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 2:18pm

Once on This Oslanf, hands down.

[UncleCharlie]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 3:35pm

Mean Girls, hands down!!!!!

 

 

Just kidding. OOTI, obviously.

[robskynyc]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 3:43pm

echoing everyone else- OOTI is a JOURNEY. super emotional . you'll laugh and cry and feel everything.

Mean Girls, as fun as it was, was just mindless entertainment.

 

Posted: 7/29/18 at 3:58pm

This is like comparing apples to a pet chinchilla.

But for me.”once on this island”

But they really don’t compare well.

[trpguyy]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 4:29pm

Mindless fun or beautiful art. Both have their places, it really boils down to what you’re in the mood for.

[Rainah]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 4:44pm

I feel OOTI is the stronger show overall. 

 

Mean Girls considerations

- easier to discuss with people who aren't in the thick of the broadway scene

- full length show

- likely to tour

- not a critical success

 

OOTI considerations

- easier to get an affordable ticket

- fantastic immersive experience 

- some consider the material to be a little dated in regards to gender politics, the show has tried to address it somewhat

- very unlikely to tour at all

- only 90min

- the lead is out for the next 2-3 months with a broken foot, however her understudy is also much praised.

[IdinaBellFoster]

Posted: 7/29/18 at 6:40pm

I love MEAN GIRLS far more than most on this board, but the clear choice is ONCE ON THIS ISLAND. MEAN GIRLS will be running for a long time, and touring. ONCE ON THIS ISLAND is an experiencethat cannot be be replicated.