Latest Headlines View More Articles
Latest Headlines View More Articles
Remembering IRENE In Honor of Debbie, Carrie and George |
Mirvish Productions, who had produced the out-of-town tryout in Toronto back in 1972 posted this on Facebook today (sorry for the all-caps, it's a direct copy and paste so it was them, not me):
MIRVISH PRODUCTIONS HONOURS DEBBIE REYNOLDS
LEGENDARY STAR OF STAGE AND SCREEN STARRED AT THE ROYAL ALEXANDRA THEATRE IN THE MUSICAL 'IRENE' IN 1972
DAUGHTER CARRIE FISHER HAD HER FIRST PROFESSIONAL JOB IN THE SHOW'S CHORUS
MIRVISH WILL DIM MARQUEE LIGHTS OF ALL ITS TORONTO THEATRES ON THURSDAY, DECEMBER AT 8 PM
The world is in shock to learn of the death of Debbie Reynolds only a day after that of her daughter, Carrie Fisher. In 1972 at the venerable Royal Alexandra Theatre, both these legends appeared in the same show.
Debbie Reynolds was starring in an adaptation of the 1919 Broadway musical IRENE. The show was having its out-of-town tryout before moving to Broadway. Miss Reynolds, who would be away from home for at least two years due to her commitment to IRENE, was delighted that her daughter, Carrie Fisher, had gotten a part in the chorus of the show — at 16, her first professional role as an actress. They would be together for the entirety of the show’s run. (Carrie Fisher would return to the Royal Alex in 2011 to star in her acclaimed one-woman show, WISHFUL DRINKING.)
In Toronto, IRENE would make theatrical history. (The story is recounted in the book “The Royal Alexandra Theatre: A Celebration of 100 Years” by Robert Brockhouse. The excerpt is below.)
But here David Mirvish remembers IRENE and the incident that would make it live on in theatre lore:
“IRENE was on its way to Broadway and it was the first and only time that Sir John Gielgud had directed a musical. In the tradition of out-of-town tryouts the show was rewritten every day and rehearsed in the afternoon and the new material put into the show at night. It is an exhausting process.
"A meeting was held in the Royal Alexandra Theatre — Jerry Minskoff, the producer of IRENE, Sir John Gielgud, Debbie Reynolds, my father (Ed Mirvish) and I were all present. We were informed by Jerry that Debbie had lost her voice and that we would therefore have to cancel the show.
“It was early winter, late in the afternoon and in the midst of a blizzard. My father explained that it was too late to contact the subscribers from Buffalo, who would have already left to come to the show, and asked if there was nothing that could be done.
“My father then said that it was thought that if Sir John, who was among the greatest actors of the 20th century, read the telephone book any audience would be appreciative.
"After a long pause, Sir John offered a possible solution and Debbie Reynolds graciously supported him.
"Taking a segment from the plot of the film SINGIN’ IN THE RAIN, in which Debbie Reynolds had starred at the age of 19, Sir John suggested that Debbie could mime the role and Sir John would supply the words.
"The overture was played, the curtain raised and Debbie danced her way across the tops of six pianos while Sir John from the wings said 'and now Miss Reynolds would be singing these words.’
"Theatre history was made that night.
"Anyone who was in the audience was delivered a performance they would never forget. Two great legends of the theatre refused to allow the weather or loss of voice to defeat them.
"In the chorus of this production was a 16-year-old named Carrie Fisher.
“We are truly saddened to have lost both Carrie and Debbie within a day of each other. In fact, it is difficult to understand such a tragedy.
“They were legends who enriched all our lives.”
***********
Excerpt from “The Royal Alexandra Theatre: A Celebration of 100 Years” by Robert Brockhouse, published by McArthur & Company, 2007:
It’s difficult to imagine the pairing of Debbie Reynolds, bubbly star of Hollywood musicals, and Sir John Gielgud, the dignified British Shakespearean, but they once performed together on the stage of the Royal Alexandra, although few in the audience knew about it at the time. It happened in November 1972, in a revival of the 1920s musical IRENE.
IRENE had played at the Royal Alexandra three times before, twice in 1921 and once in 1923. It had done well on Broadway, but the touring production was seen as a vehicle devised principally to promote the would-be star Dale Winter, wife (widow, actually) of the Chicago gangster Big Jim Colosimo, who was believed to have been shot down by Al Capone, although no one ever proved it. Dale had taken singing lessons from Enrico Caruso, but that didn’t help much and IRENE had remained forgotten until 1971, when playwright Hugh Wheeler rewrote it and producers Harry Rigby and Jerome Minskoff restaged it, hoping to take advantage of the craze for vintage musicals sparked by NO, NO, NANETTE.
Sir John Gielgud was the producers’ curious choice as director - he had done opera, but had never directed a musical - and Debbie Reynolds was the star. The show had its pre-Broadway tryout at the Royal Alexandra and disaster struck when Debbie Reynolds, with a full house in attendance, lost her voice; she was unable to speak above a whisper. There was an understudy, but she had not yet rehearsed. Ed Mirvish claimed the dubious credit for what happened; he suggested that Miss Reynolds go on, act and dance, and that Gielgud stand in the wings and read her lines.
Ed may have been inspired by Debbie Reynolds’ role in the film SINGIN’ IN THE RAIN, in which she stood backstage and provided the speaking and singing voice for an inept silent film star to mime before a live audience. It worked in the movie, but not in real life. The Toronto audience was furious at hearing Miss Reynolds’ songs recited by “some man.” Half the audience walked out at intermission, and the theatre had to refund almost everyone’s money. Ed Mirvish always expressed puzzlement at the failure of his idea. He had given the theatre an historic moment, the first (and last) musical performance by one of the 20th century’s greatest classical actors.
Wow what a bizarre story! Guess you could call it a testament to Reynolds' commitment?
Love that picture as well.
Carrie and Debbie were two of my very favorite people of all time, no hyperbole. Was just listening to Mr. Irving in Year Without a Santa Claus...
Mr. Nowack, I don't know where you get all of your production shots, but it's always a pleasure to get to browse through them.
I HATE this week. I know George end Debbie and I met Carrie several times. I cannot stop crying. This year has been awful. I haven't cried so much since the 80's when I went to over 100 memorials.
Scarywarhol, most of the ones I post are from the NYPL digital collection. I also utilise the MCNY site occasionally and even rarer my own personal collection (books and LP jackets) if i can't find them online. So glad you enjoy them :)
In September 1974 Irene played the massive Arie Crown Theatre in Chicago where in addition to Debbie, Ruth Warrick and Patsy Kelly of the obc Ron Hussman played the male lead and Hans Conried (who was recovering from a recent heart attack and walking thru the role) was Madame Lucy
.I'd have to dig out the Stage bill to know for certain but I'm wondering if Carrie Fisher would have been in the ensemble at that time - anyone know?
joined:5/9/05
joined:
5/9/05
Additionally, did anyone here see Debbie in Women of the Year? Unlike many critics, I loved this musical!!!!!


joined:10/13/03
joined:
10/13/03
I saw her 2nd performance in "Woman of the Year," and she was quite wonderful, easily the best of the three Tesses, because she was a true triple threat: she sang, she danced, and she made a persuasive case that she was a globe trotting journalist. You could actually believe that she'd done all the things the show says she'd done. (Bacall and Welch, whatever else they brought to it, not so much.) They re-did "One of the Boys" so that she really danced, and it took the roof off. They also re-instated a ballad, the name of which escapes me, and she sang it beautifully. Because she could sing. It was in every way an accomplished performance, and for my money, it made the rather bland show (though I like the score) make sense.
I seem to remember the general consensus at the time agreeing with you that Debbie lifted Woman of the Year well above the original version with Bacall. No disrespect to Bacall. I also seem to recall a new/revised cast album with Reynolds but it may be old age and wishful thinking. Anybody?
Sadly Debbie did not record Woman of the Year, although an excellent quality soundboard is in circulation:
Debbie was supposed to be terrific in Woman of the Year, elevating an inferior musical, but word of mouth on the show was out and tickets weren't flying out of the box office. Debbie got conveniently "sick," and she could not return to the show. Louise Troy, her understudy, I believe, took over and it closed in a week. But, again, general consensus was that she was clearly the best Tess.
I should have mentioned that I saw WOTY twice, with Bacall and Welch, and sitting through the show a third time would have been unbearable.( I probably was in the majority on that one.) I wish the Debbie / Gower Champion AnnieGet Your Gun made it to NYC in the late 70s. It got terrific reviews and was rumored to to be coming in, but Debbie wanted to get back to California after the Washington run.
In honor of noradesmond's wishful thinking I whipped up a mock cover for a rerecording with Debbie:
There may or may not be an edit of the aforementioned soundboard to go with it that folks need only PM me about...
Saw it at The National Theater or Ken Cen in DC prior to Broadway. Was a big deal, as Sir John Gielgud was just fired as the director and Gower Champion took over in DC. Saw it with parents in H.S. and liked it a lot. Remember thinking that Debbie Reynolds was one of those rare talents who could do it all. Had great stage presence. Liked it a lot better than the touring production of No No Nanette, that I saw about the same time (though prior to) as Irene.That cast had Don Ameche, Evelyn Keyes and Anne B. Davis. I remember my mom saying maybe with Ruby Keeler it was special with Evelyn Keyes it was a "meh."
I saw Ruby Keeler in the role twice and, other than nostalgia value, she was not a significant presence in the show. There was the showstopping 'I Want to be Happy' and that was about it. It was truly an ensemble show and two of her co-stars won Tonys, Helen Gallagher and Patsy Kelly. She probably had the 5th or 6th largest role.
I would bet that it was not Ruby Keeler's absence that hurt the show (other than the nostalgia value).
I saw Irene in Philly and it was a pile of mediocrity. The cast was fine, but the book and songs just didn't gel.There was no magic and with a vehicle as lightweight as Irene, you're going to want some magic. Right after I saw it, the shake-up began.
Debbie put on her big girl pants and said to the producers to fire Gielgud (which cost a fortune since they had to pay him his royalties during the entire run of the show), hire Gower Champion (also an expensive proposition; Gower didn't come cheap), and to delay the NY opening.
The run in DC was hastily added (and just as hastily sold out) and loans were taken to cover the massive overhaul. The NY opening was delayed also by about 5 weeks and the work began. By the time Irene came in, it was in good enough shape to wow audiences and Debbie worked like a Trojan to keep show selling out. After matinees in particular she was known to take her bow and head off-stage where her assistant met her with a towel and a handful of pens. Debbie would pat off the sweat as best she could, grab the pens and head out the pass door and into the lobby. She signed every autograph, answered every question and posed for every picture. If that didn't help word-of-mouth, I don't know what could.
Was Irene a hit? Well, yes and no. When a show takes out loans they have the repayment priority after opening. The show sold out the (then new) Minskoff and made a fortune for the year Debbie played in NY. After Jane Powell took over the grosses fell, but they made a little money during most of the 5-6 months she played. Debbie played about 5 months on the road again to sold out houses, and Jane came back to continue the tour to okay grosses.
However the weekly nut was huge; between Debbie, Gower and Sir John, that is probably 20+% right there and then there were other royalty participants and a big chorus. The featured players didn't come cheap either. Most of the operating profits went to pay off the loans, and when the investors began to share in the profits, Debbie was gone from NY. Rumored they only got back 15 cents on the dollar.
Ah, show biz. I miss it.
I saw Irene after Gower Champion fixed it. It was enjoyable enough and Debbie was wonderful in it. it just wasn't a first rate musical. What were they thinking hiring John Gielgud as a director?? Some things amaze me. Like hiring Martin Scorcese to do a musical for Liza Minelli.. (the Act aka Shine It On) Gower attempted to fix that one too!
I ran to see Debbie in Woman of the Year early in Debbie's run. And she was out. Louise Troy was on. It wasn't very good with Louise Troy. Debbie couldn't have done Women in the year for more than one week.
Saw it and enjoyed it. Certainly not great theatre, but enjoyable for what it was. Debbie was a true star, and I enjoyed Ruth Warrick and George S Irving, as well as the timeless Patsy Kelly. I just remember Debbie singing 'the world must be bigger than an avenue' and feeling like she owned the Minskoff. And she was a whirlwind of gracious at the stage door.
Jarethan said: "I saw Ruby Keeler in the role twice and, other than nostalgia value, she was not a significant presence in the show. There was the showstopping 'I Want to be Happy' and that was about it. It was truly an ensemble show and two of her co-stars won Tonys, Helen Gallagher and Patsy Kelly. She probably had the 5th or 6th largest role.
I would bet that it was not Ruby Keeler's absence that hurt the show (other than the nostalgia value).
"You are thinking of No No Nanette with Keeler, Gallagher, Kelly, Only Patsy Kelly was in Irene
joined:11/12/13
joined:
11/12/13
EDIT: Deleted. Tried to post in one board and ended up in another.









joined:2/2/14
joined:
2/2/14
Posted: 12/29/16 at 7:11pm