Skip to main content Skip to footer site map

Page: 1



American Idiot or Rock of Ages?

rorschach37
Broadway Star
joined:4/3/10
Broadway Star
joined:
4/3/10
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#1
Posted: 4/5/10 at 2:15pm
I am torn between theses two shows. I can't decide which one I should see. Rock of Ages looks like a really fun time with some great talent and music, however American Idiot looks amazing as well, full of young talented actors/singers and superb lighting and production design. I've read some reviews of both and the most-occuring opinion is that American Idiot isn't as good as Rock of Ages story-wise, but I still love how it has a rock opera feel. Is there anyone who has seen both who can give me an idea as to which one would be a better choice?
Updated On: 4/5/10 at 02:15 PM
Trainwreck Profile Photo
Trainwreck
Stand-by
joined:3/4/10
Stand-by
joined:
3/4/10
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#2
Posted: 4/5/10 at 2:22pm
Having not seen either, I'd certainly rather see Rock of Ages. Not a big Green Day fan.
Shows Seen - Swing!**, Rent (Broadway)**, The Lion King***, Wicked*****, Legally Blonde***, Chicago****, Cats***, Fiddler on the Roof***, Burn the Floor**, In the Heights***, Hair*****, A Christmas Story**, Rock of Ages***, Vanities*, Billy Elliot****, Next to Normal*****, 9 to 5**, Mary Poppins***, Guys and Dolls***, Aladdin***, Les Miserables*****

Upcoming Shows - Cinderella, Oklahoma!, Damn Yankees, Rent

Paramount Theater and 5th Avenue Theater season ticket holder

Proud Gleek
Mistress_Spouzic Profile Photo
Mistress_Spouzic
Broadway Star
joined:11/12/06
Broadway Star
joined:
11/12/06
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#2
Posted: 4/5/10 at 3:16pm
Theyre so different... I love em both. Rock of Ages is just silly fun. American Idiot is much darker and heavier.
JP2 Profile Photo
JP2
Broadway Legend
joined:6/2/07
Broadway Legend
joined:
6/2/07
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#3
Posted: 4/5/10 at 3:59pm
They're both completely different.

Rock of Ages is silly fun. It's really funny, has an amazing cast, and for a juke box musical, the music could not be used any better. The choreography is also stellar.

American Idiot doesn't have much story, or developed characters, or an overall point. But, if you're a Green Day fan you'll probably absolutely love it.
singalongsong2 Profile Photo
singalongsong2
Broadway Legend
joined:3/11/08
Broadway Legend
joined:
3/11/08
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#4
Posted: 4/5/10 at 4:56pm
I love both shows. No matter which one you choose, you will see a great performance from an energetic cast.

See ROA if you want to laugh and hear some great 80s tunes.

See American Idiot if you want something more serious, shorter in length (it's only 90 minutes long), or if you are a Green Day fan.

Again, they are very different shows, but I don't think you can go wrong either way. :)
taylorPHENOMENON2 Profile Photo
taylorPHENOMENON2
Broadway Legend
joined:3/17/08
Broadway Legend
joined:
3/17/08
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#5
Posted: 4/5/10 at 5:24pm
I think they're both fine choices, but I think if I was looking for a more entertaining evening out I would go to Rock of Ages. I do enjoy both though.
siny
Broadway Star
joined:2/8/07
Broadway Star
joined:
2/8/07
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#6
Posted: 4/5/10 at 7:32pm
Only see American Idiot if you are a fan of Green Day. There is not much else to the show. I saw both Rock of Ages and American Idiot and I enjoyed both, but they are as different as can be. The actors in American Idiot are a lot more talented and bring more energy to the show than the actors in Rock of Ages, but Rock of Ages has a better story and more laughs. How about see both ?
Updated On: 4/5/10 at 07:32 PM
touchofgr3y
Swing
joined:6/25/09
Swing
joined:
6/25/09
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#7
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:18pm
As others have said, American Idiot is really only for big Green Day fans. I've seen both and liked Rock of Ages *SO* much more. It's goofy fun, but it doesn't try to be more than that.
TheColorOfFlame
Featured Actor
joined:8/31/04
Featured Actor
joined:
8/31/04
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#8
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:32pm
Just to be a voice of dissent, I prefer American Idiot. I think Rock of Ages is the stupidest humor ever, and I think the cheesy 80's rock ballads are so bad. American Idiot has beautiful arrangements, and although I'm biased because I have friends in the cast, I think it's a more enthralling show.

Personally, I think they both wear out their welcome before the finale - but Rock of Ages is way more annoying to me.
"I am the sound of distant thunder, the color of flame." CARRIE the Musical
Mother's Younger Brother Profile Photo
Mother's Younger Brother
Broadway Legend
joined:12/17/04
Broadway Legend
joined:
12/17/04
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#9
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:36pm
For what it's worth, I don't consider myself a "big Green Day fan" (other than a few songs I've heard on the radio) and I thought American Idiot was brilliant. I saw it twice during it's Berkeley run and would've seen it more if I had the time.
JP2 Profile Photo
JP2
Broadway Legend
joined:6/2/07
Broadway Legend
joined:
6/2/07
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#10
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:40pm
"The actors in American Idiot are a lot more talented and bring more energy to the show than the actors in Rock of Ages, but Rock of Ages has a better story and more laughs."

I think both casts are EQUALLY talented. The ROA cast members bring a lot to the plate. Mitch Jarvis and Adam Danheisser are reason enough to see the show. Yes, the AI cast is pretty fantastic, but so is ROA.
sgv123
Broadway Legend
joined:8/16/06
Broadway Legend
joined:
8/16/06
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#11
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:44pm
For AI--I think that Green Day fans will like it and theater fans. It is not just for Green day fans at all.
rorschach37
Broadway Star
joined:4/3/10
Broadway Star
joined:
4/3/10
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#12
Posted: 4/5/10 at 8:59pm
Thank you all very much for your answers. I think I'll be seeing Rock of Ages this time around, but I may be going back to New York in the near future, so I think I'll check out American Idiot then. I really hope I get to see Constantine, Mitch, Lauren, and Adam!!!

Updated On: 4/5/10 at 08:59 PM
siny
Broadway Star
joined:2/8/07
Broadway Star
joined:
2/8/07
American Idiot or Rock of Ages?#13
Posted: 4/5/10 at 9:38pm
I was not a Green Day fan before I saw AI, although I knew and liked a few of their songs. But after seeing AI I am now a huge fan. But you do have to at least like their songs if you want to enjoy the show.