It's interesting that you start your list at 1972. Follies still won best score, and Verona beat out out two shows which are certainly more "commercial": Grease - which would go on to become the longest running broadway show - and Jesus Christ Superstar - which despite being quite a phenomenon was not even nominated for the top prize.
Pirates is probably their only show with the necessary pizzazz for today's theatre scene, however I'm very partial to both Patience and Gondoliers (which has their best score, IMHO)