The Voysey Inheritance has been nominated for several awards. These include Performance (Obie Awards) for Michael Stuhlbarg, Outstanding Revival of a Play (Outer Critics Circle Awards), Outstanding Set Design (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Derek McLane, Outstanding Costume Design (The Lortels) for Gregory Gale, Outstanding Director (The Lortels) for David Warren, Outstanding Revival (The Lortels) for Atlantic Theater Company, and Outstanding Scenic Design (The Lortels) for Derek McLane.