The Dazzle has won several awards, including the Performance (Obie Awards) for Peter Frechette, Performance (Obie Awards) for Reg Rogers, and the John Gassner Playwriting Award (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Richard Greenberg. The show has also received recognition for Outstanding Broadway Musical (Outer Critics Circle Awards), Outstanding Set Design (Outer Critics Circle Awards) for Allen Moyer, Outstanding Play (The Lortels) for Roundabout Theatre Company, and Outstanding Scenic Design (The Lortels) for Allen Moyer.