Trelawney of the 'Wells' has been nominated for several awards. It received nominations for Outstanding Costume Design at the Drama Desk Awards, with Theoni V. Aldredge being recognized for her work in this category. The show also received a nomination for Outstanding Lighting Design, with Ian Calderon being acknowledged for his contribution. Additionally, Trelawney of the 'Wells' was nominated for Outstanding Revival at the Drama Desk Awards.