Edinburgh Festival
Click Here for More Articles on Edinburgh Festival

EDINBURGH 2014 - BWW Reviews: MENTAL, Pleasance Popup, August 23 2014

August 24
5:49 AM 2014
EDINBURGH 2014 - BWW Reviews: MENTAL, Pleasance Popup, August 23 2014

The set up for Mental is a little unconventional. Although the show is a sell-out the crowd being picked up by taxi at the Pleasance is a small one. We are taken offsite to a secret venue which appears to be in the middle of nowhere. After removing coats, shoes and leaving bags in a separate room we are led into a small room with a bed in it. Provided with cups of tea, the audience are encouraged to get comfortable on the floor cushions and get under the duvet.

While this all sounds fairly pretentious, the reasoning soon becomes clear. This is a safe space. James is in the bed under the duvet and giving himself a pep talk in order to start the show. He explains when he emerges that the subject matter is heavy and he hopes that everybody will be comfortable with it.

This is not a play or any kind of traditional piece. It is a true life account of James' mental health problems and told in a very informal manner. He shows us the thickness of his medical records and talks us through his doctors notes and his complete mental health history. He talks about his numerous suicide attempts in great detail, both from his own point of view and from that of medical staff.

This was a truly extraordinary experience. Mental is brutally honest and you can see that some of it is difficult for James to talk about. He did a fantastic job and perservered even when he seemed to get a little overwhelmed. It is hard going and the venue staff have arranged a walk back to the original meeting point to allow people to get some air. Almost everyone looks visibly shaken when leaving and quite a few are in tears. This is a difficult and emotional piece but so important. The setting was ideal as we were away from the noise of the festival and this is a performance that should be kept intimate for comfort of both the audience and the artist.

Related Articles

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Natalie O'Donoghue Natalie has been an avid theatre goer since her first London production of Blood Brothers when she was 12. Based in Glasgow, she also reviews (read more...)

  • BWW Interview: Ian Stroughair On ICONIC: A BRIEF HISTORY OF DRAG
  • BWW Review: CHICAGO, King's Theatre, Glasgow, 19 September 2016
  • PHOTOBLOG: Behind The Scenes At Glasgow's King's Theatre
  • BWW Review: TRAINSPOTTING, Citizens Theatre, 16 September 2016
  • POLL: What stops you from coming to the Edinburgh Fringe?
  • EDINBURGH 2016 - PHOTOBLOG: BWW at the Fringe


    Harlequin Eastwood Theatre for Youth
    (Runs 5/24 - 5/27)
    Chitty Chitty Bang Bang in ScotlandChitty Chitty Bang Bang
    Festival Theatre
    (Runs 10/5 - 10/16)
    Briton Ferry Musical Theatre Company
    (Runs 10/4 - 10/8)
    Gangsta Granny in ScotlandGangsta Granny
    King's Theatre
    (Runs 10/5 - 10/9)


    Save $$$ on Tickets to:
    Backstage with Richard Ridge
    Back to Falsettoland w/ OBC - Passing the Torch
    Backstage Bite
    TV Exclusive: BACKSTAGE BITE with ALADDIN's Rodney Ingram!
    Turning the Tables
      Chewing the Scenery with Randy Rainbow
    TV:-LuPone's Autobio - Lands EVITA!
    LION KING Cast Roars at Broadway Sessions