BWW Reviews: THE WHIPPING MAN an Incredible and Telling Experience

April 4
6:30 AM 2013

BWW Reviews: THE WHIPPING MAN an Incredible and Telling Experience

Playwright Matthew Lopez is a master at weaving jaw-dropping moments of revelation with stirring soliloquies on faith and perfectly placed gems of humor. His provoking drama, "The Whipping Man," which received its Bay Area premiere this week at Marin Theatre Company, leaves the minds of viewers rolling, eager for more answers, but pleased to spend hours mulling over the motivations and choices of the play's three characters.

Wounded confederate soldier, Caleb, returns to a home in ruins. Delirious from infection and haunted by memories of death and violence, his survival depends upon former slaves, Simon and John. Their common faith ties them together as they improvise a Jewish Passover celebration, but suppressed feelings from years of slavery threaten to tip what little balance the broken household possesses.

In these moments, Lopez tastefully deals with the relationship between owner and slave, the liberated slave's open future, sex abuse before emancipation, faith's role in remembering history and its reliability in the middle of chaos and pain, man's hypocrisy and inability to obtain moral perfection, and definitions of family, forgiveness, and love. The dialogue engrosses even when the action stops, and when on-stage adrenaline rises, so does the power of the production.

L. Peter Callender carries the production as the fatherly Simon. His rousing second-act sermon on freedom gives Goosebumps, and Callender's beautiful, deep voice adds an extra dimension to the show with soulful spiritual hymn. Tobie Windham starts out with a great deal of prankster humor as John, but transforms with skill and incredible intensity as goading questions lead John to cries for justice and disorienting sorrow. Rounding out the cast, Nocholas Pelczar makes the wavering Caleb a relatable human with which the audience sympathizes and grows.

With direction by Jasson Minadakis, the three actors create a striking picture, that unfolds before a stunning set design by Kat Conley highlighted by Ben Wilhelm light design. The production will surely be the most moving theatrical experiences many audience members will ever have.


Marin Theatre Company
Through April 21

Photo Credit: Kevin Berne

San Francisco THEATER Stories | Shows  Like BWW SF  Follow BWW SF

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Harmony Wheeler Harmony Wheeler is the Marketing Director for Sierra Repertory Theatre and the Marketing and Events Coordinator for Columbia Chamber of Commerce. She also volunteers with (read more...)

  • BWW Review: THE ADDAMS FAMILY at Playhouse Merced
  • BWW Review: PHANTOM Continues to Mesmerize in Reimagined Tour
  • BWW Review: Sacramento is 'On Top of the World' with New HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME
  • BWW Review: Lamplighters' NEW MIKADO is Excellence Itself
  • BWW Review: NICE WORK IF YOU CAN GET IT Has a Fascinating Rhythm
  • BWW Review: Music Circus CABARET Somber and Relevant


    A Night at the Mint, or, The Great Heist Caper Affair... Thing in BroadwayA Night at the Mint, or, The Great Heist Caper Affair... Thing
    Mountain View Center for the Performing Arts
    (Runs 11/6 - 11/6)
    OMG, I Love That Show! Productions
    (Runs 10/7 - 11/6)
    Matilda the Musical in BroadwayMatilda the Musical
    San Jose Center for the Performing Arts
    (Runs 3/7 - 3/12)
    Shotgun Players
    (Runs 3/31 - 12/20)


    Save $$$ on Tickets to:
    Backstage with Richard Ridge
    Back to Falsettoland w/ OBC - Passing the Torch
    Backstage Bite
    BWW TV Exclusive: BACKSTAGE BITE with Katie Lynch and PARAMOUR's Ruby Lewis!
    Turning the Tables
    Randy Rainbow w/ FIDDLER Cast
      Chewing the Scenery with Randy Rainbow
    ROCK OF AGES Reunion Takes Over Tonight's BROADWAY SESSIONS