BWW Reviews: Walnut Street's THE MUSIC MAN Marches in the Holidays

December 1
8:12 PM 2012

BWW Reviews: Walnut Street's THE MUSIC MAN Marches in the Holidays

The Music Man originally opened on Broadway in 1957 and ran for 1,375 performances. The show's success on Broadway led to two film adaptions (1962 and 2003) and two Broadway revivals (1980 and 2000). 

True classic theater fans will never tire of Willson's timeless musical score with beloved songs including "Till There Was You", "Ya Got Trouble," "Goodnight My Someone," and the show-stopping "Seventy-Six Trombones.

Of course it always helps if you have an amazing leading cast and ensembleBWW Reviews: Walnut Street's THE MUSIC MAN Marches in the Holidays and The Walnut delivers just that. The production features Philadelphia's Jeffrey Coon as "Professor" Harold Hill and Broadway's Jennifer Hope Wills as Marian Paroo, along with 30 local children and a live horse! Pretty much a dream role for Coon, who has been in so many Philly productions we've lost count. Coon captures all the elements of the lovable, swindling traveling salesman. He commands the stage with fine acting and his amazing baritone and the crowd agrees.

Professor Hill never counts on falling in love with the lovely maiden Marion the Librarian. But then most of us fall in love with Jennifer Hope Wills in the title role.  Ms. Wills, who has played Phantom's Christine for four years, has only to open her mouth to sing to captivate the audience with her pitch perfect soaring sweet soprano voice. The chemistry between the two is convincing, though Wills character is not as strong willed as one may hope for.BWW Reviews: Walnut Street's THE MUSIC MAN Marches in the Holidays

The rest of the principle cast is so entertaining that it is difficult to pick a favorite. River City mayor Shin (Bill Van Horn) and Mrs. Shin (Alene Robertson) are pretty much the "show within the show" displaying a keen sense of comedic delivery.

The children are as talented as the adults.  Jared Brito and Lisa Diaz (Winthrop Paroo and Amarylis) are simply a delight. Brito's much anticipated "Gary Indiana" is innocent and believable.BWW Reviews: Walnut Street's THE MUSIC MAN Marches in the Holidays

Set in River City Iowa 1912, the fast-talking con man "Professor" Harold Hill arrives promising the townsfolk that he can teach the town's children how to play in a magnificent marching band if they buy uniforms and instruments from him. It's all part of a big swindle as he one by one hood winks the starchy Mid West residents into believing he is the savior of the city while dipping into their pockets to support his charade.

Rounding out the cast are Philly favorites Mary Martello who plays Mrs. Paroo, the doting Irish mother patiently nudging her daughter into marriage and Fran Prisco who plays Marcellus Washburn, Hill's cohort. Prisco is delightfully light on his feet and almost turns" Shipoopi" into an enjoyable musical number!

Marc Robin's choreography and direction are fresh, inventive and lively. Colleen Grady's costumes are lovely.

The Music Man plays at the Walnut Street Theater through January 6th. For tickets and information: 215-574-3550 or 800-982-278 or ticketmaster 

Photo #1 Jennifer Hope Wills (Marian the Librarian) and Jeff Coon (Harold Hill) Photo #2 Nicholas F. Saverine Oliver Hix), Bill Van Horn (Mayor Shinn), Alene Robertson (Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn), Sarah Meahl (Zaneeta Shinn) Photo # 3 Joey Abramowicz, Stanley Martin, Kevin Munhall and ensemble - Photo Credits: Mark Garvin.

Philadelphia THEATER Stories | Shows

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Pati Buehler Pati has been involved with various aspects of the theater from hosting large groups to Broadway shows in the early 90's to supporting various Broadway artists for charities such as the "Make A Wish Foundation", The Leukemia Society, and Gilda's Club, programs supporting fighting ovarian cancer. New York's Jane Ellisa's Shining Star Award for the Leukemia Society. In 2001, she began writing for various theater-based web sites from,, and

Her passion is Arts and Education and Fundraising for Non Profit Organizations. In 2002 she teamed up with Broadway star Craig Schulman (Les Miserables/Phantom/Jekyll & Hyde) to put together a traveling Broadway in your school Workshop/Master Class program that has thrilled young artists and theater groups across the country.

She began producing live concert events as PB Entertainment in 2003 at various venues. From 2004-2006 she produced two seasons of professional events for Eastern High School Performing Arts Center, Voorhees, NJ including Neil Berg's "100 Years of Broadway", two Rockin' Oldies events, a Broadway cast Jazz Show and the Southern New Jersey Philharmonic Orchestra featuring Australian world class violinist Martin Lass and more. In 2013 Pati produced “Broadway Sings For Newtown” bringing 6 Broadway artists together to perform for the Newtown Conn. Community to benefit the “Healing Arts Foundation” and honoring all the families involved in the Sandy Hook School tragedy.

Venue Affiliations: Theater Reviews: Forrest Theater, Merriam Theater, Walnut Street Theater, The Academy of Music, The Kimmel Center, Peter Nero & the Philly Pops, Media Theater, Lenape Regional PAC, The Arden Theater, The Prince Music Theater, The Paper Mill Playhouse, The Bristol Riverside Theater, Commerce Bank Arts Center, Surflight Theater, Society Hill Playhouse, Philadelphia Theater Company and more.

Events Producer: Ritz Theater Company, Ocean City Music Pier, Collingswood Foundation For the Arts , Stafford Township Performing Arts Center, Mainstage Center for the Performing Arts , Eastern Center For the Performing Arts, Newtown Conn. Arts Festival.

Pati owns and manages PB Entertainment LLC. and is a director for a private fundraising company Fundagroup.


Gwynedd Mercy Academy
(Runs 11/10 - 11/19)
Shawnee Playhouse
(Runs 6/17 - 9/2)
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Hopewell UMC Drama Ministry
(Runs 6/17 - 6/26)
Old Schoolhouse Players
(Runs 7/15 - 7/24)
School Of Rock
Popovsky Performing Arts
(Runs 8/12 - 8/14)