BWW Reviews: Walnut Street Theatre's LOVE STORY - Charming Yet Heartbreaking

September 17
6:37 PM 2012


Based on Erich Segal's novel, Love Story tells the tale of upper-class Harvard student, Oliver Barrett IV, and his life-changing encounter with Radcliffe music major, Jenny Cavilleri. They meet in a library where the quick-witted Jenny charms Oliver into taking her for coffee. Though they're from different worlds, the two fall madly in love. Like any great love story, they make mistakes, work out compromises, face great trials and love passionately through it all.

The Walnut Street Theatre's production is charming while also heartbreaking. The extremely emotional story sweeps you through two romance-filled hours, all hinging on the grandiose and authentic chemistry between the two leads - Will Reynolds as Oliver and Alexandra Silber as Jenny.  The opening number does nothing to lessen the utter sadness at the finale but you're left with an account of love that is relevant and inspiring.

The production elements of this show were almost perfect.  The set was ideal and stylishly incorporated the orchestra onstage.  The newlyweds' dinner scene was a particular favorite that was delightfully staged.  The lighting warmly showcased the lovers and their journey. However, despite the pretty attire of the cast, the costumes didn't really show the class differences between the families. 

Overall, the Walnut Street Theatre's Love Story is a romance that will transport you out of your seat and into the heart of Oliver and Jenny's amorous world.  But be sure to bring your tissues and a loved one–this show's definitely a tearjerker.

Performances of Love Story by the Walnut Street Theatre run through October 21, 2012.  For tickets and more information, visit

Photo Credit: Mark Garvin

Philadelphia THEATER Stories | Shows

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Rebecca Goering Rebecca Goering is excited to share her love of Philadelphia theatre with! Trained in voice and piano, Rebecca holds a Bachelor of Arts in both music and theatre production from the University of Delaware. She loves all aspects of theatre and has assumed a great assortment of roles in acting, stage managing and directing throughout Pennsylvania and Delaware. Rebecca is currently the Associate Director of Marketing & Communications for the Annenberg Center for the Performing Arts at the University of Pennsylvania. Rebecca was also the founder/editor-in-chief of the blog,, for which she received national recognition and critical acclaim.


Gwynedd Mercy Academy
(Runs 11/10 - 11/19)
I Love You, You're Perfect, Now Change
Mountain Playhouse
(Runs 8/2 - 8/14)
Getting to Know... The Sound of Music
StageArtz Limited
(Runs 5/19 - 6/11)
Kiss Me, Kate
Act II Playhouse
(Runs 5/17 - 6/12)
Getting to Know... The Sound of Music
Bucks County Youth Company
(Runs 8/2 - 8/13)