BWW Reviews: National Yiddish Theatre Charmingly Chronicles the Jewish Immigrant Experience in THE GOLDEN LAND

December 18
6:57 PM 2012


Review by Stephen Hanks

Have you ever wondered what might have happened to Tevya and Golde and their whole mishpucha had there been a sequel to Fiddler on the Roof?

Well, the National Yiddish Theatre-Folksbiene's production of The Golden Land may be the most unique way to find out how immigrant Russian Jews faired on New York's Lower East Side after fleeing the Czars at the end of the 19th/beginning of the 20th centuries. The English-language musical punctuated by a mostly Yiddish score is reopening Thursday, December 20 (and will run through January 6) following an initial five-week run that ended on December 2. After its first preview at the end October, Hurricane Sandy had forced the producers to cancel the next nine performances (at the Baruch Performing Arts Center, 55 Lexington Avenue at 25th Street).

The re-opening gives audiences another chance to see a delightful, if flawed, show which is essentially a fictionalized and theatrical version of a PBS documentary on the Jewish immigrant experience in New York (from the turn of the 20th century to the birth of the State of Israel), and built around a score that might be called the "Yiddish Theatre's Greatest Hits." Of the 40-plus musical numbers either hinted at (there are some scenes that include just a few bars of three or four songs) or sung whole in the two-hour production, the majority are Yiddish-language songs, with a few offering English lyrics. Sprinkled throughout this chronological history lesson are songs about the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory Fire and The Great Depression, a silent movie clip to represent the Jews who became Hollywood film producers, and a recreation of a Yiddish-language radio show, complete with vintage commercial bits.


In staging The Golden Land this year, co-creators Zalmen Mlotek (also the show's Musical Director/Pianist/Conductor and Folksbiene's Artistic Director) and Moishe Rosenfeld are celebrating the 30th anniversary of when the show was first commissioned and performed. There have been many productions through the years, the most recent one a fully Yiddish version produced in Montreal and directed by Bryna Wasserman, who also directs the newest incarnation of the show.

Thanks to a game and energetic group of six actor/singers (photo above, clockwise from left, Andrew Keltz, Sandy Rosenberg, Cooper Grodin, Stacey Harris, Bob Ader, and Daniella Rabbani) who navigate their way through many scene and costume changes, Wasserman (also Folksbiene's Executive Director) is able to tell the story at a borderline breakneck pace without the show seeming too frantic to follow. Oy vey, it's not easy to cover almost 50 years of history in two hours, but Wasserman somehow manages to make the staging work. The downside is that when you're conveying the story of one particular family's experiences over almost half a century-and doing it through more than 40 songs-it's difficult to develop the individual characters enough for the audience to feel invested in them, no matter how charming the cast may be. Hence, The Golden Land comes across as more of a revue or a mini-opera than a traditional book musical.

The seven-piece band led by Mlotek makes one sigh mechaya (with joy), and the klezmer-infused delivery of beautiful Yiddish songs reminds once again why it would be a shame if this wonderful language became extinct. There were song highlights for each member of the cast, including Sandy Rosenberg and Andrew Keltz on the Act I ballad "A Brivele Der Mamen (A Letter to Mother)," the diminutive and adorable Daniella Rabbani on "Oy, I Like Him," the handsome Cooper Grodin on a song about a good union man called "Motl The Operator," the lovely Stacy Harris on the World War II era song, "Papirosn (Buy Cigarettes)," and veteran actor Bob Ader getting into the act in Act II with a heartfelt "Brother, Can You Spare a Dime?"

If you can spare the time and 55 bucks, you should definitely experience this charming musical history lesson about how Tevye and Golde might have faired in America's greatest city. The Golden Land is being performed at the Baruch Performing Arts Center, 55 Lexington Avenue at 25th Street. For tickets, which are $55, call 866/811-4111, or visit, where you can also see the schedule of performances from December 20 to January 6, 2013.

Off-Broadway THEATER

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Stephen Hanks During more than 30 years as a magazine publisher/editor/writer for a variety of national magazines and websites, Stephen Hanks has written about sports, health and nutrition, parenting, politics, the media, and most recently, musical theater, and cabaret. While by day, Stephen is the Advertising Sales Director for Habitat Magazine (a publication covering life in New York Metro area co-ops and condos), by night he writes reviews and columns about New York City cabaret for Stephen also writes feature stories about cabaret for Cabaret Scenes Magazine. From 2010 to mid-2014, he served as the first Board President of Manhattan Musical Theatre Lab, which workshops new musicals in New York City (he is now a member of the MMTL Advisory Board. Stephen is also the founder, producer and director of the Broadway Musical Fantasy Camp, which is a workshop for amateur performers that rehearses and presents staged readings of classic Broadway Musicals. In 2011, Stephen was an Associate Producer for the Off-Broadway show THE FARTISTE. In 2013-14, Stephen staged his debut solo cabaret show, "Beyond American Pie: The Don McLean Songbook" at the Metropolitan Room in New York. Please contact Stephen with your comments and questions at:


Ripe Time
(Runs 2/26 - 2/28)
Cita a ciegas (Blind Date)
Repertorio Español
(Runs 11/8 - 6/30)
Antlia Pneumatica
Playwrights Horizons
(Runs 3/11 - 4/24)
Señorita 744890 (Miss 744890)
Repertorio Español
(Runs 2/9 - 6/30)
Red Speedo
New York Theatre Workshop
(Runs 2/10 - 3/27)