BWW Reviews: THE SAVANNAH DISPUTATION Offers Saucy and Serious Wit

May 4
11:37 PM 2014
BWW Reviews: THE SAVANNAH DISPUTATION Offers Saucy and Serious Wit

Portland Stage closes its 2013-2014 season with a sharp production of Evan Smith's saucy, yet serious comedy, The Savannah Disputation, as play which examines the foibles of faith and the thorny issues of religious dogma.

Smith's 2009 play, set in his native Savannah, recounts the story of two aging sisters, Mary and Margaret, whose devout Catholicism is challenged by the visit of a fundamentalist missionary, Melissa. Engaged in a dialogue against their will, the sisters soon find themselves plunged into a full-fledged theological disputation, which prompts them to call for reinforcement from their parish priest. The ensuing heated and hilarious conversation tests the tenacity of each of the character's beliefs.

Smith's dialogue is searing, his wit acerbic, and his sense of pacing astute. "Starting with semi-logical premises and taking them step by semi-logical-step into the realm of nonsense" (Smith's own description), he builds a taut one hundred minutes of laughter often tinged with the bitter sweet. The quartet of characters is sharply drawn: the doctrinaire Mary, the sweet believer Margaret, the energetic, enthusiastic, slightly dim Melissa, and the intellectual apologist, Father Murphy.

Paul Mullins directs with a keen sense of timing, allowing each character his almost aria-like solos, while maintaining a sensitive ear for the ebb and flow of the "contest."

Maureen Butler brings a vulnerable presence to the spinster sister Margaret, who is bullied by Mary, terrified by her own mortality, and desperate for the confirming comfort of unquestioned beliefs. Christine McMurdo-Wallis is a sharp-tongued Mary, bristling with anger repressed behind a mask of righteousness. Given the most pointed lines, McMurdo-Wallis makes the most of the part without ever turning her into a shrew or losing audience sympathy, especially at the end. Courtney Moors is perfect as the bouncy, blond, young missionary, touchingly naïve in her inflexible proselytizing. Charlie Kevin portrays Father Murphy as a quiet man given to scholarly apologies, yet willing to acknowledge and accept his inability to penetrate the mysteries of life. The four play well off each other - the only criticism being that no attempt is made to deliver Smith's dialogue with the Southern cadences in which it is written.

BWW Reviews: THE SAVANNAH DISPUTATION Offers Saucy and Serious WitBrittany Vasta's attractive unit set with its backdrop skrim of a lush, magnolia-lined suburban street and its characterful interior décor, creates the perfect forum for this disputation. Hugh Hanson's costumes underscore the personality differences among the characters, his Barbie doll outfits for Melissa especially amusing. Andrew Hungerford's lighting design bathes the stage in warm pastels, mauve and baby blue, all deceptive softness surrounding the discord within the house. As always Seth Asa Sengel contributes a crisp sound design, though the choice of interval music is curious.

With The Savannah Disputation, Portland Stage concludes a season of provocative plays. Never afraid to challenge its audience with ideas or to ask them to listen and think, as well as laugh and enjoy, this Maine company adds spice and substance to Portland's cultural scene.

The Savannah Disputation runs April 22-May 18, 2014 at Portland Stage, 25 Forest Avenue, Portland, ME. Call 207-774-0465 or visit for tickets and information.

Photos courtesy Portland Stage, Aaron Flacke, photographer.


*/ ?>

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold Born and raised in the metropolitan New York area, Carla Maria Verdino-Süllwold took her degrees at Sarah Lawrence College and Fairleigh Dickinson University. She began her career as a teacher and arts administrator before becoming a journalist, critic, and author. In addition to contributing to Broadway World, her theatre, film, music and visual arts reviews and features have appeared in Fanfare Magazine, Scene 4 Magazine, Talkin’ Broadway, Opera News, Gramophone, Opéra International, Opera, Music Magazine, Beaux Arts, and The Crisis, and her byline has headed numerous program essays and record liner notes. She also authors the blog, Stage, Screen, and Song ( Among her scholarly works, the best known is We Need A Hero! Heldentenors from Wagner’s Time to the Present: A Critical History. She helped to create several television projects, serving as associate producer and content consultant/writer, among them I Hear America Singing for WNET/PBS and Voices of the Heart: Stephen Fosterfor German television. Her first novel, Raising Rufus: A Maine Love Story appeared in 2010. Her screenplay version of the book was the 2011 Grand Prize Winner at the Rhode Island International Film Festival. She is also the author of a second novel, The Whaler's bride, and a collection of short stories, BOOKENDS Stories of Love, Loss, and Renewal. Ms. Verdino-Süllwold now makes her home in Brunswick, Maine.


Save $$$ on Tickets to:
Home for the Holidays in MaineHome for the Holidays
(Runs 12/15 - 12/22)
PDP Kids Rock! in MainePDP Kids Rock!
(Runs 10/1 - 10/9)
Disney's 101 Dalmations in MaineDisney's 101 Dalmations
(Runs 8/6 - 8/6)
Smokey Joe's Cafe in MaineSmokey Joe's Cafe
(Runs 2/12 - 2/28) PHOTOS CAST
Cabaret in MaineCabaret
(Runs 9/23 - 10/9)
Smokey Joe's Cafe TEEN in MaineSmokey Joe's Cafe TEEN
(Runs 3/4 - 3/6)