The Engeman's SWEET CHARITY - A Classic Tale Never Gets Old

September 13
3:20 PM 2012

The Engeman's SWEET CHARITY - A Classic Tale Never Gets Old

Neil Simon's Tony nominated classic, Sweet Charity, is the quintessential tale of a young woman trying to find love and running into the wrong guys in the process. We've all been there. Now playing through October 28th at the beautiful John W. Engeman Theatre in Northport, Long Island, this production proves that a timely tale never truly gets old.

Leading the cast is Broadway vet Sarrah Strimel (Catch Me If You Can, Rock Of Ages) who wonderfully portrayed our heroine, Charity Hope Valentine. Her voice was beautiful as she was part of eleven of the fourteen numbers of this two act musical. Her performances of "You Should See Yourself", "If My Friends Could See Me Now" and "Where Am I Going?" were all well received by the nearly sold out audience. However, Ms. Strimel could have added a little more schtick to her Charity, but that might have been my preconception.

Kudos to Jamie LaVerdiere for taking on three roles in this production. His first role was Charlie, Charity's moocher boyfriend, we meet briefly in the beginning of the show. He then portrays Vittorio, a womanizing Italian movie star that Charity encounters. He shined, however, as Oscar, a C.P.A. who falls for Charity. His charm and comedy brought many laughs. In one scene, Charity and Oscar are unexpectedly trapped in an elevator. Oscar is claustrophobic and he was trying to convince Charity, who is calm, that he is fine. Of course, he's doing this moving about rapidly, jumping on the railings, and shortened of breath. Ms. Strimel and Mr. LaVerdiere were indeed an adorable and relatable couple.


Also fun to watch were Lisa Karlin and Debra Walton as Nickie and Helene, respectively. Nickie and Helene are Charity's best friends and co-workers at the Fan-Dango Ballroom where they are Hostesses/Dancers. They were a fantastic team and their voices and personalities complimented each other very well. Their rendition of "Baby Dream Your Dream" was a standout number. Additionally, in Act One, they perform "There's Gotta Be Something Better Than This" with Charity pondering careers beyond dancing which was well received.

As good as everyone was, I got at several points where it seemed like the cast was simply going through the motions; very little emotion and concentration on "what's next". In a fifteen-person cast, I expected more of that "punch" that I usually get from the Engeman productions.

The set, by Kevin Judge, was minimal, yet effective, for the Engeman's high standards. An impressive skyline of New York City, complete with occasionally flickering lights for windows, aligned the back of the stage for the entire show. For the dressing room at the Fan-Dango Ballroom, they had a bench and moved a few pieces of the back of the stage for mirrors and rolled out lockers. For Vittorio's apartment, they had a bed/nightstand set. There was a few big dance numbers (this is a Bob Fosse piece, after all) so the stage was pretty much clear for a good portion of the show.


John Davenport did an excellent job with the costumes. Charity had a little black dress and periodically had on different jackets. One piece that stood out was a beautiful white feather trimmed floor length dress worn by Ursula, Vittorio's mistress portrayed by Lisa Donmall-Reeve. Another highlight was at the beginning of act two where Charity and Oscar encountered the parishioners of the Rhythm of Life Church, a group of hippies. They were donned with headbands, braids, and psychedelic clothes.

Sweet Charity at The John W. Engeman Theatre of Northport, Long Island, is certainly a hit in a fantastic season. This production, though not the strongest of material, boasts a wonderful cast and every theatre patron should see this classic piece.

Sweet Charity is presented through October 28th. Book By Neil Simon, Music by Cy Coleman, Lyrics by Dorothy Fields, Directed by Alan Souza, Musical Direction by James Olmstead, Choreography by Al Blackstone, Scenic Design by Kevin Judge, Costume Design by John Davenport, Lighting Design by Todd Wren, Sound Design by Craig Kaufman, Hair and Make-Up by Mark Adam Rampmeyer

Photo Credits: Michelle Demetillo and AnnMarie Snyder

Long Island THEATER Stories | Shows

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Melissa Giordano Melissa has been covering theatre for BroadwayWorld for the past five years and has loved every second of it. She is consistently inspired by the (read more...)

  • BWW Review: A Practically Perfect MARY POPPINS At The Engeman
  • BWW Review: Theatre Three's Annual Production of Charles Dickens' A CHRISTMAS CAROL
  • BWW Review: THE SCARLET LETTER at The Bay Street Theatre
  • BWW Review: Hampton Theatre Company's NOVEMBER
  • BWW Review: The Engeman's 1776


    HAIRSPRAY LIVE! Latest - The Journey of HAIRSPRAY- From Screen to Stage and Back Again!
    Parade in BroadwayParade
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 5/13 - 6/11)
    Elf the Musical in BroadwayElf the Musical
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 10/29 - 12/24)
    Who's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf? in BroadwayWho's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf?
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 1/7 - 2/5)
    Annie Jr. in BroadwayAnnie Jr.
    Studio Theatre L.I.
    (Runs 11/19 - 12/31)
    Vanya and sonia and masha and spike in BroadwayVanya and sonia and masha and spike
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 2/18 - 3/19)


    Save $$$ on Tickets to:
    Backstage with Richard Ridge
    JERSEY BOYS' Mark Ballas
    Backstage Bite
    BACKSTAGE BITE Thanksgiving Special!
    Turning the Tables
    BWW TV LAST MINUTE with Randy Rainbow Congas to ON YOUR FEET!
      Chewing the Scenery with Randy Rainbow
    Randy Rainbow Checks in w/ Liza to Chat HAIRSPRAY, Pence & More!
    SHUFFLE ALONG Reunites at Broadway Sessions!
    Advertisement AdvertisementAdvertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement