BWW Reviews: NEXT TO NORMAL at Theatre Three - 'You Don't Know' What You're Missing

May 23
6:36 PM 2012


The Pulitzer and Tony award winning musical, Next To Normal, by Brian Yorkey and Tom Kitts, is a force to be reckoned with. For its Long Island premier, now playing through June 23rd, Jeffrey Sanzel's incarnation of this dark, rock musical at Theatre Three provides the audience with an honest and heartbreaking glimpse into a family dealing with many varied emotions.

Diana, a mother and wife, has been struggling with bi-polar disorder for years. She is married to Dan (Steve McCoy) and they have two children, Gabe (Dylan Whelan) and Natalie (Marissa Girgus). They live a typical suburban life, but her disease is tearing her family apart. After meeting with her doctors, Dr. Fine and Dr. Madden (both portrayed by Steve Ayle) Diana undergoes electro-shock therapy despite its immense risks in hopes of fixing everything.

Linda May was sublime as Diana. Her performance of "You Don't Know" brought me to tears; there were moments where you could feel her unbearable pain. What struck me most was, at the beginning, you thought she was fine and then she's making sandwiches on the floor. I overheard wonderful comments on how she, in essence, brought awareness of the pain to those who may not have dealt with this disease.

Also brilliant was Theatre Three veteran Steve McCoy as Dan. The performance of "Who's Crazy" / "My Psychopharmacologist and I" spoke of who is the actual crazy person as Dan tries to cope and really let Dan's vulnerability come through.

Marissa Girgus was fantastic as Natalie, the troubled, young, overachieving daughter. Her beautiful voice shined when she performed "Superboy and the Invisible Girl" with Gabe. She meets classmate Henry, portrayed by Brett Chizever, and they begin to date. Her troubles take a toll on her as she begins to experiments with drugs and clubbing and Henry tries to help her deal with her demons.

The band, lead by Ellen Michelmore, was amazing. They were practically sitting in the audience. Their close proximity was extremely effective, taking everything on stage to another level. Rounding out the band was Jim Carroll on Drums, Mike Chiusano on Bass, Mike Orioles on Guitar, Nicole Cagione on Violin, and Annette Perry-Delihas on Cello.

Theatre Three's presentation of Next To Normal captured the heartache a family through great acting and moving music. Head over to Port Jefferson, Long Island to see why Next To Normal is a Tony and Pulitzer winner... and bring tissues.

Next To Normal is presented by Theatre Three of Port Jefferson, Long Island through June 23rd. Directed by Jeffrey Sanzel, Music Direction by Ellen Michelmore, Scenic Design by Randall Parsons, Costume Design by Kristy Leigh Hall, Lighting Design by Robert W. Henderson, JR, Properties by Julie Hoffman, Technical Direction Neil Creedon of Avancy, Production Stage Manager is Michelle Manda. For more information and to purchase tickets please call 631-928-9100 or visit

Long Island THEATER Stories | Shows

About the Author

Get Author Alerts
Melissa Giordano Melissa has been covering theatre for BroadwayWorld for the past five years and has loved every second of it. She is consistently inspired by the (read more...)

  • BWW Review: A Practically Perfect MARY POPPINS At The Engeman
  • BWW Review: Theatre Three's Annual Production of Charles Dickens' A CHRISTMAS CAROL
  • BWW Review: THE SCARLET LETTER at The Bay Street Theatre
  • BWW Review: Hampton Theatre Company's NOVEMBER
  • BWW Review: The Engeman's 1776

  • Advertisement Advertisement


    HAIRSPRAY LIVE! Latest - Countdown to HAIRSPRAY LIVE!: The Cast Chats About Why The Musical is So Important Today
    The NErd in BroadwayThe NErd
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 11/19 - 12/18)
    Parade in BroadwayParade
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 5/13 - 6/11)
    Miracle on 34th Street in BroadwayMiracle on 34th Street
    The Richie Applebaum Theater, At CK Productions
    (Runs 12/10 - 12/28)
    Holiday Spectacular on Ice in BroadwayHoliday Spectacular on Ice
    The Gateway
    (Runs 12/15 - 1/1)
    Who's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf? in BroadwayWho's Afraid Of Virginia Woolf?
    Merrick Theatre and Center for the Arts
    (Runs 1/7 - 2/5)


    Save $$$ on Tickets to:
    Backstage with Richard Ridge
    JERSEY BOYS' Mark Ballas
    Backstage Bite
    Thanksgiving Special!
    Turning the Tables
    Randy Rainbow w/ FIDDLER Cast
      Chewing the Scenery with Randy Rainbow
    Randy Rainbow Checks in w/ Liza to Chat HAIRSPRAY, Pence & More!
    Open Mic'ers Bring It All to Broadway Sessions!
    Advertisement AdvertisementAdvertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement