Question about Nancy Walker's version of "I'm Still Here"

chanel
Leading Actor
joined:1/28/04
Leading Actor
joined:
1/28/04

She sang it at the live concert/taping "Sondheim: A Musical Tribute" (1973). You'd never believe Nancy could have ever been a "sloe eyed vamp," but still, she did a great version, full of humor, pathos and zing. But here's my question: When she sings, "I've been through Brenda Frazier and I'm here," it gets a HUGE laugh from the live audience. It practically brings the house down. In 1973, I was young and had never heard of Brenda Frazier, a Depression-era socialite. Was her name still that much of a punchline in 1973? Maybe Nancy made some hilarious gesture when she sang that line? Maybe someone was there--and is still here, lol--and can report.

chanel
Leading Actor
joined:1/28/04
Leading Actor
joined:
1/28/04
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #2
Posted: 6/30/16 at 7:38pm

Adding weirdness to this: In 1977, I saw the revue "Side By Side By Sondheim" on Broadway. One of the songs done was "I'm Still Here," and when the singer got to the Brenda Frazier line, a young gay near me started screaming with laughter! He was the only one. No one else even tittered!!! I felt the guy must have listened to that Musical Tribute album and assumed, from that audience's reaction, that it was a huge laugh line, so he generously obliged with guffaws.

chanel
Leading Actor
joined:1/28/04
Leading Actor
joined:
1/28/04
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #3
Posted: 6/30/16 at 8:18pm

Correction: The line in question is actually "I got through Brenda Frazier, and I'm here."

morosco Profile Photomorosco Profile Photo
morosco
Broadway Legend
joined:7/10/04
Broadway Legend
joined:
7/10/04
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #4
Posted: 6/30/16 at 8:25pm
Was it a surprise lyric to many at that time? Wasn't the original lyric, "I've Lived Through Shirley Temple"?

Or do I have it backwards? Which was first?

Updated On: 6/30/16 at 08:25 PM
amaklo
Swing
joined:5/2/15
Swing
joined:
5/2/15
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #5
Posted: 6/30/16 at 8:37pm

"Brenda Frazier" was the original lyric, and it was a pretty arcane reference even back in the 1970s.  I have no idea why it got such a big laugh.  Maybe it was because the audience hadn't heard that name in 40 years?  

Not too long ago it was changed to Shirley Temple, probably so the audience wouldn't spend the rest of the song wondering who the heck Brenda Frazier was.

PalJoey Profile PhotoPalJoey Profile Photo
PalJoey
Broadway Legend
joined:3/11/04
Broadway Legend
joined:
3/11/04
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #6
Posted: 6/30/16 at 9:41pm

 

Are you kidding. Nancy Walker could get a laugh out of anything.

But Brenda Frazier is FUNNY.

 

WhizzerMarvin Profile PhotoWhizzerMarvin Profile Photo
WhizzerMarvin
Broadway Legend
joined:5/26/05
Broadway Legend
joined:
5/26/05
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #7
Posted: 6/30/16 at 9:53pm

I much prefer Brenda Frazier to Shirley Temple. I think it's the way you can single the word Frazier that's funny. Ann Miller cracks me up way she sings Frazier on the Papermill recording. Even if you don't know who she was, Miller tells you all you need to know!

Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco. Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!
chewy5000 Profile Photochewy5000 Profile Photo
chewy5000
Broadway Legend
joined:12/1/09
Broadway Legend
joined:
12/1/09
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #8
Posted: 6/30/16 at 10:41pm

WhizzerMarvin said: "I much prefer Brenda Frazier to Shirley Temple. I think it's the way you can single the word Frazier that's funny. Ann Miller cracks me up way she sings Frazier on the Papermill recording. Even if you don't know who she was, Miller tells you all you need to know!

This is very true.

 

IMHO I see Queenie as being more of a brunette...
chanel
Leading Actor
joined:1/28/04
Leading Actor
joined:
1/28/04
Question about Nancy Walker's version of #9
Posted: 6/30/16 at 11:21pm

If "Brenda Frazier" was intrinsically funny in 1973, it wasn't four years later, because as I pointed out, in Side By Sondheim, it got crickets (except for one giddy male). I suspect that Nancy Walker accompanied her great vocalization of the song with some priceless face and hand gestures.

BROADWAYWORLD TV

Save $$$ on Tickets to:












Advertisement