Hello! I have a large collection of playbills that I no longer have much interest and am desperate need of some cash. I am more than willing to negotiate prices and I like to keep all orders over $20 if possible. These are almost all the playbills I have for sale! PM if you're interested or have questions! PayPal is the best way for payments. Packages Pride package: Fun Home Curious Incident On The 20th Century It Shoulda Been You The Fish in Dark Something Rotten $40 $17 package: If/Then Opening Night Les Mis ORC Bridges of Madison County - Addams Family, The (Tour) $3 Aida (w/ Idina Menzel & Adam Pascal) Taking Offers All My Sons (200 $5 American Idiot (OBC) $10 Annie (Original Revival Cast) $7 Anything Goes (signed by Original Tour Cast) $20 Awake and Sing! (w/ Mark Ruffalo) $5 Baby It’s You (OBC) $5 Beautiful (w/ Chilina Kennedy) $5 Beauty and the Beast (OBC) $7 Beauty and the Beast (w/ Anneliese van der Pol) $5 Billy Elliot (OBC w/ Santino Fontana) $10 Billy Elliot ( tour w/ Ben Cook) $8 BKLYN (OBC w/ Eden Espinosa and Karen Olivo) $8 Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson (OBC w/ Benjamin Walker & Bryce Pinkham) $10 Book of Mormon, The (OBC) $15 Book of Mormon, The (Cast Signed w/ Matt Doyle) $20 Book of Mormon (O2NT Cast w/ Ben Platt) $8 Book of Mormon, The (1NT w/ Mark Evans) $5 Book of Mormon, The (2NT w/ David Larsen) $5 Catch Me If You Can (OBC w/ Aaron Tveit) $15 CATS (National Tour) $3 Cat On a Hot Tin Roof (ORC w/ Scarlett Johansson) $7 Chaplin (OBC w/ Rob McClure & Jenn Colella) $8 Chicago (w/ Bebe Neuwirth) $5 Chicago (August 2011) $5 A Chorus Line $5 Cinderella (OBC signed by Laura Osnes & Santino Fontana) $50 (open to offers) Cyrano De Bergerac (September 2012 w/ Patrick Page) $3 Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (OBC w/ Norbert Leo Butz & Sherie Rene Scott) $8 Drowsy Chaperone, The (OBC w/ Sutton Foster) $15 Elf (2012 Revival Cast) $6 Evita (ORC w/ Ricky Martin & Michael Cerveris) $7 Finding Neverland (OBC) $7 First Date (OBC) $10 Ghost (OBC) $10 Ghost (Tour) $5 Gigi (ORC w/ Vanessa Hudgens) $10 Glass Menagerie, The (w/ Celia Keenan-Bolger) $8 Godspell (ORC w/ Hunter Parrish, Uzo Aduba, & Lindsay Mendez) Grease (Tour w/ Emily Padgett & Taylor Hicks) $6 Gypsy (w/ Bernadette Peters) $10 Hugh Jackman Back on Broadway $8 Harvey (w/ Jim Parsons) $6 Hedwig and the Angry Inch (w/ Neil Patrick Harris; Opening Night) $15 How the Grinch Stole Christmas (w/ John Larroquette) $4 If There Is I Haven’t Found It (w/ Jake Gyllenhaal) $7 Jersey Boys (w/ Andrew Rannells) $15 Jersey Boys (Tour) $3 Jersey Boys (December 2012) $4 Kinky Boots (OBC) $12 Leap of Faith (w/ Raul Esparza & Leslie Odom Jr.) $10 Legally Blonde (w/ Bailey Hanks & Christian Borle) $10 Lestat (w/ Carolee Carmello & Will Swenson) $10 Lion King, The (Las Vegas) $3 Little Women (w/ Sutton Foster) $12 Macbeth (w/ Alan Cumming) $10 Mamma Mia (w/ Liana Hunt) $8 Mary Poppins (OBC) $20 Mary Poppins (Tour) $3 Mary Poppins (w/ Madeline Trumble) $7 Matilda (OBC; Opening Night) $12 Motown (OBC; Opening Night) $8 Movin’ Out (OBC) $4 Murder Ballad (w/ Caissie Levy, Rebecca Naomi Jones, & Will Swenson) $10 Nance, The (w/ Nathan Lane) $7 Newsies (O1NT Cast) $7 Phantom of Opera, The (Closing Tour Cast) $7 Peter and the Starcatcher (OBC w/ Christian Borle) $10 Peter and the Starcatcher (w/ Celia Keenan-Bolger & Adam Chanler-Berat) $7 Peter Pan (w/ Cathy Rigby; Opening Night) $7 Pippin (ORC) $12 Phantom of Opera, The (June 2009) $7 Phantom of Opera, The (Las Vegas) $7 Porgy & Bess (w/ Audra McDonald & Norm Lewis) $10 Priscilla Queen of the Desert (Cast Signed Broadway) $20 Promises, Promises (w/ Kristin Chenoweth & Sean Hayes) $10 Ragtime (OBC) $30 Rocky (Pride playbill; OBC) $8 Scandalous (OBC) $7 Seussical (w/ Rosie O’Donnel) $6 Sister Act (OBC ) $10 Sister Act (w/ Raven Symone) $8 Sister Act (Tour) $3 Spring Awakening (Deaf Awakening Cast) $8 Wedding Singer, The (OBC w/ Laura Benanti) $7 Wicked (OBC) taking offers Wicked (w/ Shoshana Bean) $10 Wicked (Chicago w/ Ana Gasteyer & Kate Reinders) $10 Wicked (w/ Lindsay Mendez) $10 Wicked (signed by Derek Klena) $20 Wicked (Tour w/ Alison Luff) $6 Talley’s Folly (w/ Sarah Paulson & Danny Burstien) $5 Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike (OBC) $6 Victor Victoria (w/ Julie Andrews) $13 Young Frankenstien (OBC w/ Sutton Foster) $10
I think your several prices just aren't realistic. On a quick search of eBay, I found:
- Chaplin for $5.50 - First Date (Playbill plus flyer) for $7 [Playbill alone= $5.50) - Ghost (Playbill + postcard) for $7 - Leap of Faith for $5.50 - Little Women for $5.50 - Pippin for $8 - Porgy and Bess for $6, with a flyer
...and then I got a bit bored looking up random shows. But all the shows I looked up (those above) were cheaper-- sometimes by several dollars-- on eBay. You may want to rethink your prices considering that there are many members on this board who generously give away their playbills.
Seriously. Due to the advent of the Internet, Playbills no longer have the market value they did decades ago when vintage ones were virtually impossible to locate.
I remember pre-Internet, an original Streisand FUNNY GIRL Playbill was worth about $300. Post-Internet (and the with the birth of eBay), that same Playbill MIGHT bring in $10 today.
A once free Playbill only has marketability if it has a strong fan base. Otherwise, they are worthless.