Looking for a show!

[gabewalk56]

Hi!
So, the high school I work at is currently trying to decide on a musical. We have 5 seniors we'd like to cast as principal parts- 1 male and 4 females. One of the females is a very strong dancer/actress but only an average singer, another is a VERY strong actress but not a very strong singer or dancer, and the other two are singer/actresses. The male has a strong high-baritone voice and is a strong actor, and an average dancer.

Do any shows come to mind? We've considered Fiddler on the Roof, Peter Pan..if anyone has some suggestions that'd be incredible!