http://www.boxofficemojo.com/genres/chart/?id=musical.htm 1. Grease 2. Chicago 3. Mamma Mia! 4. Hairspray Support Broadway, add a Twibbon to your Twitter avatar now! - http://bit.ly/MCDTo

In what universe?! Big problem with that list. It doesn't take ticket price inflation into account. Only Grease would make the list. None of the other films would even come close. The real list is: The Sound of Music Mary Poppins Grease My Fair Lady West Side Story South Pacific "I first saw her on Broadway. I'd never heard of her before and then afterwards, realized what an amazing talent she is. Her singing voice is akin to hearing an angel sing. This sounds like hyperbole, but I really do mean it. I don't think in all these years I've ever heard anyone sing with such range and such beauty. She has just an exquisite singing voice. I think when America gets ahold of her, she'll go very far." - Bing Crosby speaking of Julie Andrews, 1 month before she opened in MY FAIR LADY.

There is something about undeserved success that really.. irks me. JPTV! Watch & Subscribe

Just because you say it's the real list doesn't make it the real list, JohnBoy. FIRST WIVES CLUB - THE MUSICAL "Behind every great woman...stands herself!" December 31, 2006 = Yea, I miss THE WEDDING SINGER.

Yes, but when you really take a look at their cost to their profit ratio, they really aren't that successful. Other than Grease, that is. Especially not compared to the real list, which I've posted. I mean, Mary Poppins was the Number 1 film of 1964, The Sound of Music was the number 1 film of both 1965 and 1966, that's how successful it was. All the films on the real list were the number 1 films of their perspective year. Other than Grease, none of those other films were anywhere near number 1. It's a very misleading list. "I first saw her on Broadway. I'd never heard of her before and then afterwards, realized what an amazing talent she is. Her singing voice is akin to hearing an angel sing. This sounds like hyperbole, but I really do mean it. I don't think in all these years I've ever heard anyone sing with such range and such beauty. She has just an exquisite singing voice. I think when America gets ahold of her, she'll go very far." - Bing Crosby speaking of Julie Andrews, 1 month before she opened in MY FAIR LADY.

If you click on the link it says 1974-present, live action only. It's probably true.

Regardless of what you think about the merits of Mamma Mia! the movie, its success is great for the genre. Between Grease in 1978 and Chicago in 2002, no movie musical grossed over $70 million at the US box office. (not including animated films, of course) Now, in less than 2 years, we've had 3 musicals(Dreamgirls, Hairspray, and Mamma Mia!) that have grossed over $100 million. Movie musicals have shown that they can sell tickets, and hopefully there will be many more coming down the pipeline. (By the way, the list at the original link only includes non-animated movie musicals since 1974, which is why The Sound of Music, etc are not included.)

Just because you say it's the real list doesn't make it the real list, JohnBoy. Yes it does. Not a single person in the industry would consider that list an accurate one, because you cannot compare $10.00 tickets to 50 cent ones. It makes no sense. I explained it in the post above. I mean do you seriously think that Mama Mia and Hairspray and Chicago were more successful than Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music??!! Seriously? "I first saw her on Broadway. I'd never heard of her before and then afterwards, realized what an amazing talent she is. Her singing voice is akin to hearing an angel sing. This sounds like hyperbole, but I really do mean it. I don't think in all these years I've ever heard anyone sing with such range and such beauty. She has just an exquisite singing voice. I think when America gets ahold of her, she'll go very far." - Bing Crosby speaking of Julie Andrews, 1 month before she opened in MY FAIR LADY.

The post is titled "Third Highest Grossing Movie Musical" for a reason...it doesn't say "Tops Yearly List" or "Highest Number of Movie Tickets Sold." The fact is, it has the third highest gross of a movie musical. Everyone knows movie tickets cost more these days, and inflation has occurred. It's an accurate list for what it is a list of. Your list would be labeled "adjusted for inflation," and would be looked at differently. There isn't one list to rule them all. Success is like failure; it's how you perceive it. It's what you do with it, not how you achieve it.

I mean do you seriously think that Mama Mia and Hairspray and Chicago were more successful than Mary Poppins and The Sound of Music??!! Seriously? No one said that. That's not what this list is judging. Success is like failure; it's how you perceive it. It's what you do with it, not how you achieve it.

Johnboy obviously doesn't care, so anything we say is nothing to him. This list is 1974-Present, which is why many of the musicals you named do not make the list. This is the real list for that specific time period. Get over yourself. ALICE RIPLEY FIND THIS VERY CONVENIENT FOR PLOT.

Remember that is just the Domestic gross. and internationally, the Movie is still yet to open in some countries. and ABBA and Mamma Mia has a great rep outside the US Herbie: "Honey, Don't you know there's a depression?" Rose: "Of Course I know, I Watch Fox News" -(modified)Gypsy Broadway Schedule Nov. 21 undetermined 3pm In The Next Room, or The Vibrator Play 8PM Nov. 22 Love Lost and What I Wore Nov. 24 A Little Night Music 8pm

Yes, it's true that list does not take inflation into account. However, there were no DVDs, cable viewings, or On Demand when The Sound of Music and others came out. All that stuff goes into the profit mix nowadays, and it's very important. If DVDs did not exist and cable TV was not around (or the Internet for that matter), you can bet Mamma Mia's gross would be even higher (ie, more people would have attended). Plus, movies ran many, many months in theaters back then. Yes, it is not accurate to compare this gross with older movies, but it is also not fair to dismiss the fact the Mamma Mia has performed phenomenally at the box office. Measure it against its contemporaries--right now it is the 13th highest grossing movie of 2008 in the US. Worldwide, it is the 8th highest grossing movie of 2008.

Popeye made almost $50m in 1980 dollars??? Wow... And I always forget what a hit "Best Little Whorehouse..." was. Saw "Next to Normal" on 9/25/09 and "Hair" & "Toxic Avenger" on 9/26/09. In Chicago, seeing "In the Heights" on 12/21/09 and "Addams Family" on 12/22/09.

When adjusted for inflation (based on box office mojo) the top 5 highest grossing non animated musicals are as follows: 1 -The Sound of Music ($1,008,300,900) 2 - Mary Poppins ($553,527,300) 3 - Grease ($544,606,000) 4 - My Fair Lady ($424,800,000) 5 - West Side Story ($396,269,600) http://www.boxofficemojo.com/alltime/adjusted.htm "I'm afraid that the children that the two of you would spawn would come out in costume, off book and belting Merman."

Here's to hoping High School Musical 3: Senior Year doesn't top any of those lists.

Plus, movies ran many, many months in theaters back then. Yes, on one screen per city. One. "I first saw her on Broadway. I'd never heard of her before and then afterwards, realized what an amazing talent she is. Her singing voice is akin to hearing an angel sing. This sounds like hyperbole, but I really do mean it. I don't think in all these years I've ever heard anyone sing with such range and such beauty. She has just an exquisite singing voice. I think when America gets ahold of her, she'll go very far." - Bing Crosby speaking of Julie Andrews, 1 month before she opened in MY FAIR LADY.

Here's to hoping High School Musical 3: Senior Year doesn't top any of those lists. Oh no! I didn't even think of that...you know it's inevitable. HSM2 got 17.3 million tuned in for its premiere...now multiply that by movie ticket prices. If the Hannah Montana & Miley Cyrus: Best of Both Worlds Concert could make $31,117,834 in its opening weekend alone...we're looking at HSM3 leapfrogging onto this list faster than anything. Success is like failure; it's how you perceive it. It's what you do with it, not how you achieve it.

To be honest, HSM3 being successful is fair game. Its the younger generations Grease, let them have fun with it. Plus, because it's being released in theatres and will have a massive budget...i'm hoping that they will go all out and show that they deserve the hype. From clips I've seen already, it looks far superior to its prequels.

How depressing that this brainless badly directed and poorly sung movie musical has made this much money wanna be a Zzzzzzz

"Plus, because it's being released in theatres and will have a massive budget...i'm hoping that they will go all out and show that they deserve the hype. From clips I've seen already, it looks far superior to its prequels." I wouldn't call $13 a massive budget. It's actually rather pathetic. JPTV! Watch & Subscribe

I don't get how their budget be only $13.3 million if Zac Efron, Ashley Tisdale and Vanessa Hudgens are each getting a few million. They must be paying salaries from some other pot of gold. I guess it makes Disney smart because they will get HUGE profits from it by keeping the production costs down to a minimum. Wiki is saying that HSM was made on only 5 million...so I guess they have splashed out a fair deal.

If you notice, that Mojo list doesn't even include the Sound of Music anywhere. They GOOFED big-time. And I'm only impressed with how Mamma Mia is faring against other musicals in the past few years... because that's the only way you can compare them with the current ticket prices. JohnBoy2 is right... the Sound of Music is one of the top 3 grossing movies of all time, musical or non. Click on the "adjusted" link, if you want to open your eyes to the truth. "Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."

best12bars, the list is 1974 - present. Success is like failure; it's how you perceive it. It's what you do with it, not how you achieve it.

OK, I'll play devil's advocate here. Since we've now been told the point of the post (or the expression highest gross) isn't meant to reflect its overall success, what then is the point of the post and the title if not meant to suggest that it is the third most successful? Why not just say then what you mean -- "due to the highest ticket price averages ever charged for a movie musical, Mama Mia brought in a lot more money than movies did when the ticket prices were cheap" If that's the POINT of the post, then why not just say it? It's kind of hard to believe that the whole reason for posting such statements in the first place isn't to SUGGEST that it is therefore also the third most successful movie musical. Let's be honest about that.